Do Not Implement Guest Star Call Feature
Do not implement a call feature in the sidebar.
Do not implement a call feature that is on by default.
If you implement a call feature, make it channel-specific (as it is currently) and make it OPT-IN (as it is currently.)
-
BagelGremlin
commented
since this was implimented, i did my best to turn it off and i just permaban anyone that somehow finds a way around it and knocks. I personally hate the feature and how it overtakes chats of people that didnt lock it down, causing me to misclick it if i want to chat. So I dont chat anymore.
-
BlueishMeteor
commented
Yeah this was so far sighted, really I don't want people knocking on my door IRL, let alone while streaming lol, Make it optional, for now I've turned it off but it was hidden. Do Better Twitch.
-
fluffiehamu
commented
Since this was implemented, add a way for us to paus this indefinately. I stream alone unless I ask, I do not collab. I am older and less tech savvy and if I hear a knock on god I'll **** myself.
-
DraleZero
commented
Please turn off Knock feature by default.
Please give option to turn off completely instead of workarounds. -
Azhtral
commented
Forcing us to use features we do not like is not the answer.
Implementing and improving features we ask for is the answer.
-
Vynlenn
commented
Who the **** runs and approves these new features? Whoever it is needs to be fired ASAP.
-
lushenzener
commented
Seriously, whose asinine choice was it to make this an opt-OUT feature? Did y'all just take a random schlub with an engineering degree and ZERO content creation experience and exposure outside of the crank call format to figure this one out?
-
KisaiTenshi
commented
This feature really does need to be an opt-in, or "only when I am in (category list)", because Twitch very much underestimates how willing people are going to troll others.
I'd even go one further and require that anyone "knocking" needs to be streaming at partner levels (25h+12d) so that people aren't just making throw-away accounts to harass streamers with the actual notifications.
-
heo_yui
commented
as a vtuber, this is SCARY
-
phatloud
commented
This and the DJ program is dangerous to the future of twitch.
-
kaine23
commented
this is too dangerous
-
Nate_LapT
commented
Twitter rolling out bad update after bad update.
Do they even beta test this stuff. -
ShockRizal
commented
Make guest star only available to the one initiating the call and invite only. Or else everyone would spam request when it's available for literally everyone watching.
-
TheMackV
commented
Welp, they implemented it.
But maybe they can at least change it from automatically allowing ANY invites by default to at least only Following by default? Because just unexpectedly throwing this switch open to EVERY affiliate is just begging for harassers to cause problems with it.
-
RayShadow278
commented
Absolutely Do. Not. Implement. This.
The last thing I want is for random people I don't know and have never talked to to suddenly try to barge into my stream without any control. -
ChefRyuga
commented
Do not implement this. It's a feature that is not needed nor was it asked for or even wanted. At the very least let us opt out of it PERMANENTLY instead of just "pausing" it on a per stream basis. Furthermore, this opens the door for new levels of harassment of streamers and their community. Not to mention the massive risk to minors being exposed to content they shouldn't be exposed to. Absolutely horrid idea.
-
SkiesCanFall
commented
Exactly what purpose does this feature serve? Streamers already use offsite tools to manage collaborations more efficiently and can more easily minimise the risk of someone abusing a feature to land the streamer in hot water, simply by setting up a private Discord server and using permissions effectively.
So far, the only potential use case that the CEO has been able to cite for this has been the nascent Twitch DJ program, but the vast majority of streamers aren't radio stations; they don't have a team of call handlers or call screeners to filter out the people who will inevitably use this to troll and disrupt the broadcast or try and get a streamer banned.
Can we please just stop and think first before rushing out new features. You must have a User Research team or a Service Design team of some sort, even after the latest round of layoffs. Start to think about how developer time can be better put to use by giving existing features a little TLC, rather than just releasing new ones that no-one asked for and will inevitably be depreciated after less than a year when they fail to gain any traction.
-
Adora_Bunny
commented
Discord already exists, and if this is a feature that will be seen mid-stream, will only lead to abuse and annoyance. Even call-in radio stations typically had someone to deal with the phones before they got live on air. Do not implement this in its current form.
-
protogenwave
commented
this had better be a joke. do not implement this whatever the cost, because:
* guest calls into stream
* guest says/does something against TOS
* streamer gets banned in 5 seconds without being able to control itthis is how you get your biggest money-making streamers banned overnight. think about that, Twitch. you're going to lose money if that happens. you like money, right? then scrap this feature and pretend it never happened, please.
-
DescryAU
commented
100% agree on this.