Remove "sensitive social issues" bullet point.
Twitch should remove the "sensitive social issues" clause from Article VII of its Content Classification Guidelines. LGBTQ+ people, immigrants, and reproductive rights are NOT "sensitive social issues", they are common sense issues, where one side simply wants their liberties intact. The controversy is entirely on the other side of the argument the involves taking those liberties away.
Especially as it pertains to LGBTQ+ individuals, the notion that the discussion of their very existence is political is absolute nonsense. These people should be allowed to discuss the issues affecting them without being set behind some kind of "explicit content" label. This is a slippery slope that begins with people automatically labeling non-heteronormative lives and content as "deviant" or "degenerate", especially by grossly bad actors who want to be edgy.
Remove the final bullet point from Article VII.
Thank you for raising this. We’ve just posted a Tweet addressing these concerns.
You don’t need to label your stream with the new Politics & Sensitive Social Issues CCL if you are sharing your lived experience. Intermittent mentions of politics, politicians, or sensitive social issues also do not require the Politics and Sensitive Social Issues label. We apologize for not communicating this well initially.
If you are an LGBTQ+ streamer, for example, you do not need this label when talking about your lived experience as a member of the LGBTQ+ community. We’ve added clarifying language to the Content Classification Guidelines to better express this.
-
BladeMaids
commented
Grouping LGBTQ+ people (and others) in with protest and political coverage is disgusting, something only someone who isn't LGBTQ+ would think is a good idea. I can exist without being up front that I am a liberal, but being queer is an core part of who I am. The same is true of being a woman, being an immigrant, being anything. "Twitch is for everyone" the article says, but I'm left to assume that doesn't include me.
If the implications are that only the factory settings descendants of Europeans can exist exist on twitch without being explicitly labeled as political, then the trust and safety team at twitch surely have know working knowledge of the world. This policy seems to seek to actually label people in the way people have joked: "That you are either straight or political, white or political, cis or political, a man or political" and quite frankly, if the people at trust and safety don't comprehend the issue with this while coating their ignorant policies in the landlord's rainbow paint job, then serios problems await them next time Chick-fil-A runs out of chicken nuggets and they are forced to understand the fast food worker explaining basic concepts of reality to them.
I can wax poetic (or more apt. wax sarcastic) all I want, but the core idea needing conveyance is simple: this policy is ignorant and damaging.
-
NaiNohni
commented
This is blatant segregation of a group of people and their existence. Please hire a DEI manager.
-
teacupkaizad
commented
Everything about my existence has been made political beyond my will. It should not continue into my life as a streamer.
-
Thelassa
commented
My existence, my experience, and my life do not require a content label. Shame on you.
-
kss0219
commented
My existence as a trans person is not political and to suggest it is is a huge step in the wrong direction.
-
hollyrious
commented
This is ridiculous, we should be allowed to discuss our lives and journey with our audiences.
-
ABasicDog
commented
This policy is a huge backwards step for Twitch and those that stream on the platform. The vague wording politicizes the existence of LGBTQ+ individuals and immigrants while creating yet another target on the backs of creators that fit into those groups. If Twitch actually wants to be a place to express themselves, the platform needs to work to protect and elevate streamers and their communities rather than giving bad actors another tool to abuse.
-
transgwender
commented
Queerness is not political, and the silencing of trans voices just serves to further historic injustices and harms. I hope Twitch will listen to the trans community when we say that this will cause real harm, because it will, and we should not in the first place have to be the ones to say "Hey, this will harm us". It will cause real harm, and Twitch must fix this
-
GrayGooGlitch
commented
I should be able to talk about my lived experience without a special label to protect the feelings of someone who's so sheltered that anything that isn't exactly like them is scary and confusing. ***** those people and ***** this policy.
-
Poixyn
commented
this is a roundabout way to further segregate already-marginalized people. and you're just giving a hit list to people who would use this info in a dangerous/violent/harmful way.
-
organMike
commented
It's a bad idea to give ammunition of this sort to the numerous bad actors who would weaponize it against queer and trans creators.
-
Dragonwarrior125
commented
My existence should not require a label on Twitch. If I say that I'm married, it shouldn't then become an issue of whether i tag my stream or not. This is part of why I haven't been streaming, as even existing LGBTQ+ tags will get harassment.
-
TJF588
commented
Having to watch what we say because we're living just the same as anyone else is what's political, let us be ourselves.
-
ZoeSkunk
commented
My existence isn't up for any debate, Twitch, and the only effects this policy will have is burying or destroying LGBTQ streamers/content and giving 'phobes something to weaponize with and in their harassment campaigns.
-
WrongTypeOfHero
commented
This is SO easy to abuse and mislabel.
It's not a political stream if I say "Trans Rights!" but I'm playing Terraria for the entire thing. But that doesn't matter at all, according to this, that, for some reason, does.
This can and WILL be abused if Twitch doesn't fix it ASAP. And considering how a lot of their huge creators are LGBTQ+, this will cause issues.
-
DragonC0mmander
commented
This is nothing short of discrimination against LGBTQ+ identifying persons and other marginalized groups, and will completely be used to enable bad actors to target those specific groups--EVEN MORE THAN THEY ALREADY DO--just by virtue of existing on your platform regardless of if anything actually political is being discussed.
I'm certain none of the LGBTQ+, BIPOC, disabled, and other marginalized people who currently use Twitch, myself included, appreciate being forced to be a "political streamer" just by identifying a certain way. All this does is make an already big target on our communities even bigger against our will. Chasing a large percentage of your user base off your site is a waste of resources, and isn't the flex you think it is.
-
werewolfhitchhiker
commented
My existence isn't up for debate, Twitch, and the only effect this policy will have is burying LGBTQ streamers and giving homophobes something to weaponize in their harassment campaigns.
-
SilverCatBoi
commented
Hey, are you out of your ******* minds?
-
syggles
commented
Twitch, would you require black people to have to classify their stream as sensitive social issues because people make a fuss of people of colour?
No, and doing so for LGBTQ+ only alienates and makes it easier to harass them because their existence is considered troubling to a small amount of people.
-
ToasterCatball
commented
To be fair, I get it. I know that the intended point of the clause is about providing a warning label for streams focused on legislative action. (I'm tired of getting political hitpiece ads on YouTube, myself.) That's not how the trolls and hate raiders are going to use it, and we have no guarantee that's how the moderation team is going to interpret it. Even if you do give us closure that the moderation team won't miswield this clause, how are we supposed to believe that when you guys are constantly banning VTubers under false pretenses like bits fraud? This change CAN and WILL result in banning queer creators for simply existing.