Replace AI-Generated Category Images with Human Made Work
For the creative/non-gaming categories, ESPECIALLY the art category, please replace the AI generated category images with credited, human-made images.
We've had the old category images for a while, they definitely could have used an overhaul. With the hiring and crediting of emote artists for new hype train emotes, some of us were cautiously optimistic that new category images would follow the same pattern. Twitch has a thriving creative community and it's no secret that many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. Many of us have had our work stolen with this technology.
Regardless of Twitch's view on the use of these technologies, the creative community as a whole has an overwhelmingly negative view on it—see the previous UserVoice to remove the Catinthechat emote with almost 14,000 upvotes here https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/928738-badges-emotes/suggestions/49188362-no-ai-for-global-emotes-change-catinthechat, as well as the hundreds of artists who came together to create new cats that could have easily been used for the emote. Moon worded it well in the UserVoice on the AI generated cat icons: "Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform."
Even the non-creative community seems upset at their images being AI image generations: https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/934332-customer-experience/suggestions/49173698-fix-the-ai-gerneated-category-image.
With this in mind, we ask that Twitch reconsider representing us, a community who OVERWHELMINGLY disapprove of the use of AI, with AI generated imagery that they could have instead asked one of the MANY creatives on Twitch to do. The 'Artists + Makers' creator club is full of multi-disciplined, highly creative, and very skilled folks who would be happy to take on the challenge of helping to remake not just the Art category, but all of the AI generated category images. Because, quite frankly—even with AI taken out of the picture—the new category images do not feel well representative of the groups they are supposed to be representing. For example, the Art category image captures only a sliver of the community it is supposed to represent, fine artists. It is a vibrant place filled with artists of every medium and genre! This image does not represent us well. Feel free to reach out to the members of your creator club for ideas, iteration, design, and work. We WANT Twitch to feel like home for us. We WANT to create and engage with the community. We do not want to be disregarded.
Please take advantage of the creativity and passion of your currently thriving creative community, instead of taking actions that at best read out of touch and careless towards them. If creatives feel like the platform is actively hostile towards them, that thriving community will start to dwindle. Don't do that to us.
-
ScarboSheep
commented
It's not going to be that difficult to get an image by a real artist. Don't try to validate AI being a legitimate way for art. It is not.
-
karlacade
commented
i don't know who at twitch decided that using genAI was a good idea, but it's not. way to tell your artists you don't actually care about them, twitch.
-
TheStonedLich
commented
Not only are these images appallingly ugly, they are are a massive slap in the face to the creatives who create are in those categories.
-
RemiTheTanuki
commented
Your decision to use ai generated images on a platform that hosts hundreds of thousands of artists is, quite frankly, an embarrassment. We as your user base have set no precedent to indicate that we would be okay with this decision.
Do better.
-
LunacyAndPirates
commented
Just how many times do we need to have this conversation Twitch? Your user base does not want to be associated with generative AI. Your user base is packed with creatives, you know, those people who make you money. Stop being ignorant of the issues so many people are vocal about and support your users, engage with them and work with them to create a community space.
-
IzabellaOoze
commented
I don't understand why you wouldn't just make several designs and ask the community what they think several months / weeks out? Instead you make yourselves look like you don't understand the people who make you money. Is this a matter of investing too much money in a product that was snake oil? I keep seeing all these companies using AI and nobody likes it, not only that but is ****** off the people who care the most about the subject. Also why "ART." ? Why does the image have a period at the end of it the category doesn't? Is this trying to make a statement of some sort? how about "No."
-
オクトゲイシャ
commented
me literally going out my way to make a Category cover for art by a human for @twitch (this is my gift) to support @semispri.bsky.social users voice
https://bsky.app/profile/octogeisha.bsky.social/post/3lpmrfrqfac2v
-
HeyEmilyK
commented
Do you guys not make enough money to pay a single staff artist to make images for you? Instead you have to rely on burning chunks of the planet so that a plagiarism machine can create the most sad and average looking imagery an algorithm can muster? YOU MAKE ME SAD.
-
AaraRose
commented
there are hundreds of incredible artists that use your platform every day, week, month and using generated ai images really is insulting to the hours and days of hard work it takes to complete human made art. Please reconsider hiring a real artist for any and all art used on your platform!
-
valerynorth
commented
Using generative AI for anything related to creator industry is just hugely disrespectful to your user base and the people making you money.
-
Xenosbreed
commented
You could have just NOT changed the thumbnail. Using AI to generate a thumbnail is a massive slap to the face of the very artists working under that label.
-
EvilLilLad
commented
Sad, disappointing, and frankly disgusting for a company that makes as much money as Amazon and Twitch does. Not only that but a platform that hosts some of the most inspirational and influential streamers that are either artists themselves or heavily feature art in their streams. You already knew what you should have done if you wanted to change the category images. You already knew what the public opinion would be.
Do better.
-
ThatRadioGeek
commented
Gross. Unfortunately, big corporations gonna big corporate, but this is out of touch on about a billion different levels.
AI is bad, mkay?
-
ajenbyknight
commented
AI makes stuffs look cheap and turns me off heavily.
-
AlmightyRayzilla
commented
Streaming in general is a creative feat. Categories are representative to viewers of what streamers are doing with their creativity. AI images are the antithesis to creativity; it is disingenuous to represent creativity with uncreative imagery, especially when many of the streamers I watch are incredibly creative individuals, and especially after ALL of them and their communities are very vocal about being against AI. And people all over (not just Twitch) have made it clear they do not like AI, especially when it is constantly and spontaneously being shoved down our throats.
-
xenolon
commented
How tone deaf, out of touch, and insulting can a company be to its own user base, to use as representative iconography of that group the exact thing that currently serves as an existential threat to said craft and practice?
It begins as lazy and extends to outright aggression.
-
sotomolo
commented
it's honestly amazing how twitch can see how hated AI images are and still decide that it's a good idea to use them.
-
vernkost
commented
Not only is it disrespectful, lazy, and cheap to use Gen AI Images for your category covers, the new images also look significantly worse than the old art that was used. If you wanted to change the look, you could have commissioned artists to make something that objectively looks way better.
-
Jasmineitor
commented
This is a slap in the face to any and all artists who call your platform home. There are countless artists who would jump at the opportunity to make custom work for the community, but instead you disrespect the intelligence of both your community and the artists who stream to them by using this lazy approach. It completely cheapens the platform. My livelihood as an independent artist is threatened daily by AI generated slop, let alone all of the ethical issues it causes through generation of illegal sexual content involving minors, deepfakes, etc., as well as how much misinformation is being spread as a result of people relying on these generators instead of actual factual sources - I see this action as a direct stamp of approval of these things by Twitch, and makes me question the future direction of the platform as a whole.
-
KroyVR
commented
Using AI to produce wall celery as a small-time, backroom streamer is one thing.
Using AI when you're the owner of the platform that holds a huge wealth of creative talent right there, who put themselves on air, every hour, every day. Seriously?
Run a competition, commission artists, use your community teams, schedule a rotation of art from the community. Give your creative community a voice. They would produce something that looks 10* more authentic and inspiring than the low-effort, generative AI prompt crafting that has gone into this.