Twitch category name collision
Currently two (or more) games with the exact same name (usually reboots) share the same category in Twitch. And all the cover art, description, tags are taken from only one of the games. This usually means that the other game(s) effectively completely lacks a page on twitch, despite being a completely different game and having unique gameplay. Can something be done about this?
-
Arkanogamingtv
commented
A few days ago I started playing the Mafia Game (classic version) and I have seen that there are two categories in the category selection, one with 113K followers and another with 625, it seems that someone created a new category of the Mafia game with a logo with a black background and Mafia written by hand as if it were a 3 year old. Could this be revised so that the classic Mafia game category is correct?
-
timbomelon
commented
Please update this. Another developer has just called their game Dros, we thought that nobody was going to do that! Totally different games. It is now using their art and description on our game.
-
NiteKat
commented
This is causing an issue for the Diablo game, as a new category named Diablo popped up at the end of April and now anyone playing the Diablo 1996 PC game cannot use the proper category. This being fixed would be a huge help.
-
NoobJr
commented
Resurfacing something I said a while ago: I encourage raising awareness of this issue in affected communities so that it gets more votes.
Twitch is actively ignoring this issue and providing no recourse for small communities, so the only thing we can do is get more people to complain about it.
-
FF5Ninja
commented
This is a big issue for the games Shadowrun (1993) and Shadowrun (2007). The latter is an FPS and completely different than the former. The 2007 community has seen a revival but can't properly stream on Twitch.
-
FF5Ninja
commented
I agree. As of right now Shadowrun FPS can't be found on Twitch when being streamed and this would clear up confusion.
-
santumerino
commented
I'm experiencing the same issue with my own game, YARG (released 2022, https://www.igdb.com/games/yarg) and another game by a different developer also called YARG (released 2023, https://www.igdb.com/games/yarg--1). The newer game seems to have overridden my game.
Hoping something can be done about this!
-
Llynia
commented
have the same issue with Oxygen / OXYGEN . It always jumps back to the wrong game category. Anyone knows what to do about this?
-
PonPonTheDreambunny
commented
There are currently two entires with the exact name "Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back" that links to the same category, featuring two different covers. One being the PS1-cover, and one being the remade cover.
Currently Spyro Reignited Trilogy has all games duplicated with a "- Reignited" variant added to it. But Crash does not.
I would suggest that Crash at least have "Crash Bandicoot: N. Sane Trilogy" as a single category, which I think Spyro should have as well. Users have reported that this unified category once existed, but it really should be brought back. No need to have it for each individual game, just one single category is fine.
-
hamstarV1
commented
I must point out this particular instance is NOT a matter of 2 different games with overlapping names: https://i.imgur.com/T8NisBm.png
-
NoobJr
commented
"God Of War (2005)" had its year added to the Twitch category to "fix" the collision issue even though the IGDB entry is just "God Of War". This was done manually by Twitch because it's a high-profile franchise.
Could we PLEASE have a way to do this for other games affected?
IGDB rejects game title changes because of this bug, simply pointing us to this neglected thread. If we could just fix the category itself like God Of War did, this wouldn't be nearly as big of an issue.
-
shadowash1
commented
I have been trying to find the category "Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)" but it doesn't appear in the search results on Twitch even though it has a page on the website IGDB.com which Twitch uses: https://www.igdb.com/games/sonic-the-hedgehog-473de878-5a9f-402e-a282-86a7460fc1d2
How can "Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)" be used as a category for streamers playing the game? -
S__J
commented
This is a good idea. The first person shooter game in this universe is more similar to Halo Reach or Destiny, than the Shadowrun RPG title and it is confusing, and stopping me from locating streamers of the correct game.
-
SirisSR
commented
This is becoming an issue because the other Shadowrun games are nothing like the FPS for PC/Xbox. It would be really nice to have a Shadowrun 2007/FPS/PC/Xbox category. Please help!
-
McSchwartz2
commented
Currently experiencing this issue with Vanquish (2010) and Vanquish (2022). Very different games. Currently you can only choose the 2022 one.
-
hamstarV1
commented
https://i.imgur.com/T8NisBm.png
Might be an error.
-
3MERGx
commented
Since there are already separate categories for the different Shadowrun rpg titles, the fps community is left without its own category since it shares the same name.
There’s already Shadowrun Returns, Hong Kong, Dragonfall; can either the plain ‘Shadowrun’ category be updated with the cover art of the FPS or can there be a new category made labeled ‘Shadowrun FPS’ so streamers can correctly label and stream under the fps title?
Thank you -
3MERGx
commented
Following back up about Shadowrun, the fps.
It has a separate IGDB but seems to be experiencing a name collision. Twitch already has separate game categories for the various Shadowrun rpg titles.Could Twitch update the cover art of the plain ‘Shadowrun’ to match that of the fps? Since any streamers of the rpg have their own separate categories for their respective rpg titles but the fps doesn’t have one at all. Please and thank you
-
[Deleted User]
commented
I agree with you, but you should make a suggestion to IGDB discord first.
-
andOlga
commented
It is absurd that publishers re-use names.
It is even more absurd that this issue that has had a solution for decades exists on a wobsite in 2023. Twitch, please -- this is the basic of the basics. This allows a publisher to just make your wobsite unusable for a specific older game should they so choose, or even by accident.