Twitch category name collision
Currently two (or more) games with the exact same name (usually reboots) share the same category in Twitch. And all the cover art, description, tags are taken from only one of the games. This usually means that the other game(s) effectively completely lacks a page on twitch, despite being a completely different game and having unique gameplay. Can something be done about this?
-
UncleDisco
commented
It's crazy that this is STILL an issue.
Currently stuggling with immortality from 2022, which is being confused with a totally different game with the same name -
PonPonTheDreambunny
commented
Another game merged:
Cube Runner (2016) https://www.igdb.com/games/cube-runner
Cube Runner (2008) https://www.igdb.com/games/cube-runner--1Please just make a global fix, don't rely on the game's name, add the IGDB-ID to it. First one is 30128 and second one is 72964, this solves _all_ collissions.
-
icekitsune
commented
There's only one category for Tanglewood, but two games exist with that title on IGDB:
Tanglewood (1987): https://www.igdb.com/games/tanglewood
Tanglewood (2018): https://www.igdb.com/games/tanglewood--1There also exists a bundle cartridge with Xeno Crisis & Tanglewood (2020), for which a category isn't listed on Twitch: https://www.igdb.com/games/xeno-crisis-and-tanglewood
-
NocturnalNemz
commented
5 years of these issues being reported and nothing has still been done.
After emails back and forth with Twitches basically useless generated responses and IGDB admins refusing to adjust information to a game title to solve the issue. Both continue to point the finger at each other yet refuse to acknowledge fault or a solution.
I am extremely disappointed in Twtich, they are quick to take cuts from creators but pathetic in resolving issues like this that directly impacts Indy Developers. -
periwinkle9
commented
There are currently two Cave Story categories, one which is the main game (https://www.igdb.com/games/cave-story) and one which is an unofficial (fan-made) PSP port: https://www.igdb.com/games/cave-story--1
-
gifan14072
commented
The topic of categories and overlapping titles on platforms like Twitch is always interesting, especially when it comes to choosing the right parameters to organize your content. While you’re thinking about new categories, you can take a break and relax https://joefortune-au.com/ a bit with online games. For example, on Joe Fortune’s platform, you can find plenty of entertainment to relieve stress and switch off between Twitch sessions. Play and relax to recharge your batteries for new ideas!
-
Inateno
commented
Hello, facing an issue with my game Emberfall which seems to be hard to pick since most streamers used the wrong Emberfall which leads to a dead game.
CF Links:
Any idea help would be appreciated.IGBD Links:
https://www.igdb.com/games/emberfall
https://www.igdb.com/games/emberfall--1Twitch category links:
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/emberfall/videos/all
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/emberfall-1/videos/allThanks
-
Forginal
commented
Sonic the Hedgehog (1991) and Sonic the Hedgehog (2006) are completely different games and the 2006 game doesn't have its own category.
1991: https://www.igdb.com/games/sonic-the-hedgehog
2006: https://www.igdb.com/games/sonic-the-hedgehog-473de878-5a9f-402e-a282-86a7460fc1d2 -
DragnflyVT
commented
Witch Spring 3 and WitchSpring3, both with no cover art. Both have followers. This goes for all the games in the series though I notice the versions without spaces tend to have art (just not 3).
There are mobile versions and PC remakes, but the PC ones have slightly different names (ex: WitchSpring3 Re:Fine - The Story of Eirudy for PC while mobile is just WitchSpring3) and here I notice the Steam page doesn't use spaces in the title.
It'd be nice if there was at least a form we could use or something to notify Twitch. -
ratleg
commented
currently having this issue with lifeline (2003) not showing up on twitch despite having an IGDB page, because of an unrelated 2015 game with the same title! looking up the japanese name for lifeline 2003 also pulls up the 2015 lifeline :(
-
thecurlyp
commented
I'm having the same issue with Polybius.
The joke is that the one is an urban legend and the other is real game by Llamasoft.
The real one has more followers, but I'm unable to select it
-
DJ_ZomB1
commented
There are 2 games both named Root that share the name name but differ from their gameplay.
Root (FPS): https://www.igdb.com/games/root
Root (Digital Board Game): https://www.igdb.com/games/root--1 -
vingamer234
commented
This is the issue with the Spyro the Dragon and Crash Bandicoot trilogy remasters. (the MediEvil remake thrown in, too) Kingdom Hearts has this happening with the original 2002 release as well.
I noticed this is primarily an issue with the VODs in video producer, though.
-
Zcienxe
commented
Custom Robo (2004 Gamecube) exists in the IGDB database but there is only a category for the 1999 N64 game with the same title on twitch.
GC: https://www.igdb.com/games/custom-robo--1
N64: https://www.igdb.com/games/custom-robo -
RenderingRanger
commented
There is a Name collision for this Spider-Man Game from 2002. Probably other SM games are effected but my concern is about this one particuallry
https://www.igdb.com/games/spider-man--1
thanks for fixing this and adding it to a specific category on its own
-
akoluthic
commented
This is happening with Chrysalis. When you select this game in Stream Manager (https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/chrysalis-1) the videos are put on this 1985 game instead: https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/chrysalis
-
optillusiongames
commented
New colision for While Waiting. I'm working for the puzzle game (yellow logo)
- Puzzle game : https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/while-waiting/videos/all
- Horror game https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/while-waiting-1/videos/allAs a CM, I've noticed that some of my streamers are showing up under this incorrect game category:
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/while-waiting-1/videos/allThank you for your help!
-
GMP__
commented
Just caught up on my thread and wow, so much spam about Dwarf Fortress. Anyone with reading comprehension should have realized this issue is about literally the opposite of what Dwarf Fortress had. I am glad that one is sorted but don't let the Dwarftards' replies fool you into thinking the issue I reported is sorted. The name collision issue is still a thing. It's so annoying that such a trivial thing requires a revolution to sort and on a case by case basis.
For anyone wondering how this works:
IGDB has a database of games. Their database has a unique ID for every game. Their job is to provide data via API to their partners, including Twitch. Previously Twitch had a partnership GiantBomb. This issue was present back then as well and it will persist even if they move to another data source. The reason? It is upto Twitch to decide how to process the data. Some genius Twitch dev decided that the title of the game was unique enough to identify it. Their whole URL system is based on this assumption, it just converts the game title to kebab case. The only way they are solving the issue currently is by manually mapping a custom URL (for example by appending the release year) with the appropriate IGDB page, when there is enough outrage from a specific game's community. The permanent solution will involve a change in the structure of the URL itself, which feels like twitch is not prioritizing on even though it should be the trivial task. -
Mario1080p
commented
Today's another case of this very issue. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door literally has the same exact title and now have a split viewerbase on launch day. At the time of writing the older one has 16K viewers while the remake with a different cover and fewer tags has 9K.
To me this is such a huge bummer as it hinders a remake/remasters discoverability. At the same time I don't want the older category to be erased with all the videos and clips over the years being removed.
I just wish for a clean merger without older content wiped. It always bothered me when a remake/remaster has a slightly different subtitle, but Paper Mario is a recent example where I expected everyone just used the old category because of their subtitle being the exact same.
A quick solution I can think of is the removal of the 2024 link and just change the cover of the older category like how live service games changes covers every season.
-
PonPonTheDreambunny
commented
I put together an image of what the selection on Twitch could be like: https://i.imgur.com/JDtfR4d.png
This would help clarify which game is which, similar to like Kitaru and others have suggested.
For the URL (the ID) of each game on Twitch, just add the IGDB ID at the start of the URL just like Uservoice, so for example:
/category/tetris--1 -> /category/8197-Tetris
/category/tetris-1994 -> /category/236647-Tetris