Please stop messing with our muscle memory and revert the UI change
Twitch just rolled out a change on the PC browser website that moves the panel that contains the streamer's username, stream title/category, follow button, concurrent viewers,... to the top of the stream, which not only messes with our muscle memory but also makes the experience a bit less pleasant as the stream got pushed downwards from its original centered position.
Please Twitch, if it ain't broke don't try to fix it.
-
jron5
commented
I would love for Twitch to actually listen to what the viewers want and not just brush it under the rug or being called brain rot by one of your Ambassadors when we clearly spoke about issues we didn't like (Looking at the knock feature).
The UI (experimental or not) is garbage. Even from a design standpoint, it's just awful. I would leave it alone since there's nothing wrong with it from a usability standpoint.
- The title description along with all the tags, profile pic, etc. should NOT be at the top. Our focus is the video, not some ugly bar at the top.
- If you are really trying to keep it at the top (which again, you shouldn't because it doesn't look good and detracts the viewer from focusing on the main point which is the stream), there should NOT be so much open space.
- The follow and notification buttons should not be at the top next to the title while the sub/gifting buttons are located at the bottom. Either move them all together or leave them where they are.
- Why you guys decided to remove the buttons to click on Clips or Videos is beyond me. Makes it so much more annoying for editors to have to click on their profile (where it's in a horrible position), click on videos & then swap the drop down to clips versus just clicking on "Clips" -
MentalMarsupial
commented
The platform has had massive stability problems as of late, and instead we're getting updates concerned primarily with (bad) aesthetic changes
-
AkiAndFam
commented
Not only muscle memory, but literally every platform whether horizontal or vertical has the information UNDER the video if it's not full screen. Most even in full screen have the information at the bottom (except YouTube, because that's where the timer bar is) This just breaks with normal conventions and I very much dislike this change. If anything, it should be a toggleable option (either above or below video)
-
Zilexion
commented
Hey, Twitch, if you need extra incentive to put this info back where it should be. Separating crucial info like title, tags, stream duration, etc. from the subscription buttons means users eyes wont spend as much time in their vicinity... and you wouldn't want that, right?
-
P2isonline
commented
It cuts off the screen, it doesn't reach the full width of the video, it makes the subscribe button hidden and harder to find. It just all around looks ugly and a terrible move for the website design.
-
TheRayzRayz
commented
Nice now I have black bars on the sides of the stream because all that empty space below the Stream takes up more space than the old layout. Also long titles no longer fit. Twitch somehow found a way to take up more space around the stream and fit less, crazy.
-
AllonBachuth
commented
There is no benefit to going against a decades long convention of putting the titles and interactive features below the video content. The video player is what we're there for, it should be as high up on the page as possible for optimal viewing comfort.
If you're going to put all that info up at the top, put the follow, gift sub, and subscribe buttons there as well. They look misplaced on their own row that is majority empty. -
Ulexos
commented
undo please, and next time do it as an opt-in test instead, or a test with the option to easily opt-out of at worst, thank you
-
goldenthesaltmine
commented
Clip manager changes which show how many clips of what specific channel and game or thing you've made, good.
Clip manager previews no longer taking up half the screen, good.
New twitch UI where views and the livestream time is at the top alongside other important info. ABSOLUTELY AWFUL OH MY GOD WHO LET YOU DESIGN THIS.
-
TheLtWilson
commented
In my opinion, this latest test takes away muscle memory from not only avid Twitch users, but for video streaming in general. Not only that, but it just seems very hastily and poorly designed.
1. There is no border to separate the stream information from the player. For example, there is a dividing line underneath the player and to the right where the chatbox is. Which makes the stream information look like it's not supposed to be there.
2. Why is it so dense? The stream title, game, and tags are all on the same line which makes it very difficult to quickly tell what's actually going on - which is the opposite effect of what I assume this test for.
3. This redesign kills muscle memory. Almost all streaming services present the content itself first and foremost, with extra information below the video player. Changing this behavior makes it disorienting and confusing, regardless of if it's a veteran or new user.
I'm not opposed to change, I'm usually open to it. This just doesn't seem like the right move, and I hope the test concludes soon and is reverted.
-
pinkbambibeats
commented
There was literally NO reason for this change, it's so bad.
-
nogoodcitizen
commented
put it BACK
-
Hezkezl
commented
The layout of the site isn't the problem, it's perfectly fine as is and needs to be left alone. Please dedicate time to fixing OTHER issues, like "stream streaks" not working correctly for those of us who are lucky enough to be in that group.
-
memobee
commented
Info on the top made sense in theatre mode. It does not make sense for the normal channel page player. The buttons on the bottom still make the most sense, because the lower area is where just about all of the interactive elements of the channel page are. Not having the stream information along with them is a waste of the space that it used to be in. Muscle memory or not, this change is a worse version of the site and nothing more.
-
PansGaming
commented
Really dislike the change. Much prefer when the stream title and information was below the stream. Layout was fine, didn't need changing at all.
-
OpLurker1005
commented
Can we get it changed back and stop making pointless changes that no one wants.
-
Zekriox
commented
It's disorientating to have this be changed. Please revert it back to the previous way.
-
VenomousNinetails
commented
It didn't need to be changed, stop doing anti-intellectual stuff like this and just stop wasting Twitch's and Amazon's money on dumb pet projects.
I have more to say
-
zenex4504
commented
this sucks change it back
-
LordSupremeKara
commented
It would be good to understand what the rational from Twitch was around this UI A/B testing on the live stream video player.
I think whilst people aren't liking it, it needs to be clear as to why people are not liking it.
My personal view on this so far with the limited interaction I've had with it, is the fact that it feels more sqaushed and restricting useful infromation.
With the streamers that I noticed it on, it cut off the title, which most broadcasters have commands or notices to share with their community. Yes there is a drop down option that allows the section that has the full title, all of the tags, instead of a couple in a more expanded way to look at it. This does then go over the stream itself, and whilst I would like to assume that Twitch indeded it to be a 'quick check' type approach to this design ui testing it's still frustrating having click an extra box, rather than scrolling down to see the title, tags, game, etc...
Whilst the test that I'm apart of still has the manage subscription / gift a sub and subscribe buttons below the player, this portion of the screen just feels like dead space / wasted space.
I feel that if this is a design that Twitch is seriously considering, it would be good to see what it would look like with the sub related information above the player and the video inline with the bottom of the screen.