Please stop messing with our muscle memory and revert the UI change
Twitch just rolled out a change on the PC browser website that moves the panel that contains the streamer's username, stream title/category, follow button, concurrent viewers,... to the top of the stream, which not only messes with our muscle memory but also makes the experience a bit less pleasant as the stream got pushed downwards from its original centered position.
Please Twitch, if it ain't broke don't try to fix it.
-
DanteLaDuca
commented
did you guys even do research on the positions of objects and how it affects UX ? cause this is definitely worse than before. a lot worse.
-
oteraaa
commented
please revert back to the old one and stop changing!
-
egoloco
commented
We want the old one back! I don't care if this change is to differentiate itself from other platforms. Change it back!
-
cypheroftyr
commented
Change this back, it is very awkwardly placed. Also when folks do charity streams they often put the bar at the top of the screen. I also spent way too long trying to see if a Chrome add in had changed something. This wasn't needed or honestly wanted.
-
Mareep__Sheep
commented
How do I revert this change?
-
TomosWorld
commented
absolutely terrible. WHY was this even a design choice????
This is a no go. Please revert to original state, or at least provide opt out.
its ugly -
lIRossIl
commented
horrible
-
MercuryBullet
commented
Terrible terrible design choice.
If it is just about SEO as some have suggested.. Copy the title, put it in an invisible box that doesn't change UI, and don't impact all your users with a UI decision that makes the platform uglier and worse.
The distracting crawl, the weird choice of splitting follow and sub, every single aspect of this is silly.I'll add one of my own.. at the browser, many of us use a bookmark bar. That whole area of the browser already has Tabs, adressbar, and then bookmarks... and now the title of streams, crawling. Instead of in the less cluttered below the video like it has always, for good reason, been.
Why?
If you, at the very least, told us what motivated the change.. cause.. I can't motivate it at all. -
Leubast
commented
This doesn't fix anything and actually makes things worse. With all the info crammed into the top, it pushes the stream itself further down and causes confusion. It also causes the info to be compressed where it does not show everything necessary, unlike having the info at the bottom where it can be expanded as much as needed.
There is ZERO reason for this change! -
kava_84
commented
This change is so moronic, I wood even argue who ever did this and approve this design to be fired immediately. And I always wonder, why change something that works in the first place. First fix your mobile app, then try to "fix" something else that is not even broken. It's just stupid and bad UX, it's not functional at all, looks bad, and it's impractical.
-
Folkkeyboard263
commented
I want the old one back!
-
Fluxszi
commented
This new stream title placement is incredibly distracting and ugly, it breaks UI conventions and it serves no functional purpose. You didn't even fit the title box to the size of the video! Why would I want a empty black box at the top right of the stream? Why would I want scrolling red text (viewcount) at the top center? There was already more space for the information at the bottom, and it actually fit with the rest of the UI instead of shoving everything else out of the way and leaving a conspicuous empty space because it doesn't even fit where you put it. No one is happy when you make these changes for no reason.
This is not a minor annoyance, this is a primary and central element of the user experience, and I deeply implore you to listen to your userbase this time. I could not possibly hate this change more.
-
klydeinside
commented
Terrible decision. Revert it back.
-
TheLifeIsYours
commented
Change it back, this is just bad UX
-
Peredoxx
commented
This change is honestly the worst one so far. Who approved this and thought it was better than having it below the stream? If you added an option in the settings to move it to the top, that would be fine. But the fact that I have no choice, and this was just implemented for everyone like this, is truly terrible.
-
Sitruuna
commented
EVERY UI update you guys make is SO BAD, whoever accepting these SHOULD BE FIRED!
-
Mopmopmopmop
commented
Terrible, please change it back.
-
cheese___cat
commented
this wasn't an update. it looks more like a bug that should get resolved in several days.
the placement of the title, how many people are watching and the tags up top, above the player was just a bad, bad idea. It wasn't even customized to fit the look. you guys just took whatever you had before and plopped it on top of the screen.
it's now cluttered on top, looks dogshit and leaves so much dead space below the video. It cuts the title if its long, and the expand option makes it look even worse (somehow, it goes from awful to even more horrible).
congrats twitch, you guys made one of the worst UI decisions ever
-
ivitheiv
commented
Change it back please, new layout is trash. Not because its new and different, it is just trash. Makes so more much sense to have it on the bottom, where all the rest of the text and channel info already are.
-
Gambloide
commented
This change makes almost all titles I see unreadable, because the new layout cuts them off with an ellipsis. That is awful.
The space beneath the video is now barren whitespace with only the sub & gift-sub buttons, while top is so cramped, it doesn't even fit everything it tries to fit properly. It honestly looks like someone's first try at using CSS after being told to put everything into one place.
The hidden expand-button which has NO LABEL and only appears when you hover the player, an accessibility nightmare, doesn't even work reliably when you figure out its existence and intended function. For example, I didn't manage to make it do anything on phone other than flicker in and out.