Replace AI-Generated Category Images with Human Made Work
For the creative/non-gaming categories, ESPECIALLY the art category, please replace the AI generated category images with credited, human-made images.
We've had the old category images for a while, they definitely could have used an overhaul. With the hiring and crediting of emote artists for new hype train emotes, some of us were cautiously optimistic that new category images would follow the same pattern. Twitch has a thriving creative community and it's no secret that many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. Many of us have had our work stolen with this technology.
Regardless of Twitch's view on the use of these technologies, the creative community as a whole has an overwhelmingly negative view on it—see the previous UserVoice to remove the Catinthechat emote with almost 14,000 upvotes here https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/928738-badges-emotes/suggestions/49188362-no-ai-for-global-emotes-change-catinthechat, as well as the hundreds of artists who came together to create new cats that could have easily been used for the emote. Moon worded it well in the UserVoice on the AI generated cat icons: "Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform."
Even the non-creative community seems upset at their images being AI image generations: https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/934332-customer-experience/suggestions/49173698-fix-the-ai-gerneated-category-image.
With this in mind, we ask that Twitch reconsider representing us, a community who OVERWHELMINGLY disapprove of the use of AI, with AI generated imagery that they could have instead asked one of the MANY creatives on Twitch to do. The 'Artists + Makers' creator club is full of multi-disciplined, highly creative, and very skilled folks who would be happy to take on the challenge of helping to remake not just the Art category, but all of the AI generated category images. Because, quite frankly—even with AI taken out of the picture—the new category images do not feel well representative of the groups they are supposed to be representing. For example, the Art category image captures only a sliver of the community it is supposed to represent, fine artists. It is a vibrant place filled with artists of every medium and genre! This image does not represent us well. Feel free to reach out to the members of your creator club for ideas, iteration, design, and work. We WANT Twitch to feel like home for us. We WANT to create and engage with the community. We do not want to be disregarded.
Please take advantage of the creativity and passion of your currently thriving creative community, instead of taking actions that at best read out of touch and careless towards them. If creatives feel like the platform is actively hostile towards them, that thriving community will start to dwindle. Don't do that to us.
-
TheMushroomOverlord
commented
I feel like morals and ethics aside, using gen ai in official functions of the app or marketing for any professional or official website or business reads as cheap and unprofessional. Like, there's a VISIBLE quality difference when you look at ai generated images. People can tell. It's kinda embarrassing lol
-
Naieth69
commented
Since they are not listening, I recommend changing platforms. There are options like tiktok, picarto, joystick, kick, etc. Depending on your needs.
-
GamerLudwig
commented
I'm afraid this issue is dead.
They literally started training genAI on streams.
There's a setting to turn it off at least . . . -
KaseySnowArt
commented
I am commenting to boost this because a better response to this is needed to regain any faith from the creative communities.
Twitch needs to be better about 1) ensuring no genAI imagery is used in official twitch assets (including category images, emotes, banners, marketing, etc) and 2) continuing to offer that sort of work to your MANY incredible artists who would be more than happy to work with the platform on designs of all sorts.
The hype train emotes being largely created Twitch artists lately has been wonderful. Anything other than continuing that trend is a huge step back and undoes a lot of trust within creative communities already wary of tech companies as only wanting to take advantage of our collective life's work to save a buck.
-
BagelGremlin
commented
update: instead of listening to its userbase that generative AI has no place here, Twitch has decided that it wants to also wants to feed our content- which they get for free from us and want to make us opted into by default- into generative AI to train it.
I'm losing faith that anyone at twitch actually reads these or looks at how many votes they have. Makes me want to find other platforms where the teams behind them actually do care...
-
SemiSpri
commented
Update:
It has been over a year since we initially started this feedback post. Since then we have gathered almost 8,000 upvotes and 71 pages full of comments asking Twitch to revert the category images or allow creatives from the community to create new, non-generative category images. Twitch's lack of action or even acknowledgment of this UserVoice post is a blatant disregard for the concerns of this community, and is quite frankly very disappointing. Thank you so much to everyone who has added your voice to this message, and I hope that Twitch will recognize and respond to this community at some point.Some of these category images were made using AI in blatant capacities. The definitive language regarding the Art category should be amended, though.
The Art category frame was made with stock imagery not *labelled* as AI. The image does seem improperly labelled, as the original non-generated version has been identified, though the employee photo-bashing the category image would not have been responsible for that.
The person choosing the image for the 'Fitness + Health' would have known that it was AI, as it is clearly labelled as such and contained clear visual markers indicative of generative work. 'The Food and Drink' category image has blatant and clear visual markers for AI. Folks have reasonable suspicions for other categories as well.
None of the category images should have been made with AI when Twitch has a thriving creative community eager to add to it. The positive benefit of hiring Twitch creatives for the new Hype-Train emotes has been celebrated by all parties across the board.
In light of the info that stock clearly labelled as AI was used, I think it is also fair to ask that Twitch review its stock image use policies to avoid generative work in future. It's clear from over 6,000 up-votes (updated: 7.9K+) and almost 60 (updated: 71) pages of comments that the community doesn't view the use of such technologies and their by-products favorably, nor do they feel well represented by them.
So bullet points:
- Many folks in the Art community to not feel well represented by the new category even if it hadn't been made via an expressly AI generated stock image, as it only highlights a small portion of the community compared to the previous image.
- Multiple of the category images have been made with blatant and verifiable use of AI, and we ask that these be reverted, re-designed by creatives (would be awesome if they were from Twitch!), or at the very least remade with stock that wasn't created with generative technologies.
- Twitch has a massive, thriving creative population and many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. To use it anywhere in Twitch's official assets disregards this community that has been largely exploited using this technology.
- We ask that Twitch review it's stock-image use policy and avoid using stock clearly labelled as AI in future, as much of the community does not view the technology favorably/feel well represented by itThank you to everyone who has upvoted thus far and has made their voice known. I am disappointed in this decision as a creative, but am so proud to be a part of a community so passionate and willing to stand up for what they believe in.
-
MoonlightMagpieVAD
commented
PLEASE, Twitch. We need to change these images. A lot of us won't stream in the categories we'd like to because you elected to use AI SLOP rather than genuine human art. These categories represent US, so USE US TO REPRESENT OURSELVES!!! PLEASE!!! We will not be represented by AI slop when we are out here creating and keeping art alive!!!
-
RingSong
commented
The fact that bots like WarlicNorris appeared on this topic ...
Is proof enough that many people don't want to see creative areas tarnished with generated slop in stead.Please keep generative "ai" trash out, no one is represented by something made up of regurgitated, stolen, work.
-
BBWolfe
commented
Sir, no one is stopping you from playing a game, but thank you for stopping by and writing a full load of logorrhea about this thing you don't care about.
Having our work stolen to generate these category images is absolute trash. You'd think so too, if it was your work. Sorry the bots got to you, though. Those suck.
-
WarlicNorris
commented
At this point, all I want is to be able to play a ******* game, idc about your ai art that you are PROBABLY one of those gfx artists going around spamming in people's chats ANYWAYS.
Idc... i really don't, ******** with the gfx nonsense. If I want to make ai, I can make ai.
And quite frankly, all I want is for smaller and not seen content creators seen. If ai disturbs you, ********, cus IDC.
What I do care about is saving this trash *** fuckwitish platform from corrupt advocates. This platform was made for gamers originally, not advocacy, not vtubing, and specifically not for gfx artists ******** about how they weren't ******* paid.
Idc, ********, yall pray on us smaller content creators, then report us anyways for whatever the **** reason anyways.
-
butchsquire
commented
"Art" made by machines will never replace the literal blood, sweat, and tears that we artists put into our crafts. Changing covers for creative categories to AI is a slap in the face. Even if Twitch was some small broke indie company it wouldn't justify this sh*t. The f*ck were y'all thinking.
-
KristKC
commented
EEW! Yuck! Change it. Do it now! =C
The frame looks like vomit tbh, It's gross my dude. >_<
-
TheStonedSpider
commented
The lack of intelligence surrounding AI is just astonishing but not surprising as trump was actually elected.
-
moon_sparrow
commented
I completely agree. The image for "makers and crafters" being an obvious (and ugly) AI-generated image is insulting to the makers and crafters who use the category. Twitch, please stop using AI for generating images. You could hire an artist to create category thumbnails in a heart beat.
-
AuroraPeachy
commented
AI Art is plagiarism and theft, and also simply lazy. Have some dignity, Twitch. Hire human artists.
-
CodysGC
commented
So does Twitch actually look at these? I feel like everyone here is in agreement that this is ******** that Twitch is using AI for anything.
So?... Is Twitch going to acknowledge it? or just ignore it? because clearly they care about money more than anything else. -
Auburn_Arcana
commented
As a quick follow-up, I still do not want to be represented with this category thumbnail. It does not in any capacity properly reflect what the category is about.
Art theft that steals from a countless number of people via a plagiarism machine is still art theft at its core. It comes across as an insult for Twitch to be using stolen assets to fix something that was not broken to begin with.
Twitch has the resources and means by which to nurture their artists and get something far more useful and meaningful in the process - easily. I strongly recommend that Twitch pursue these means immediately.
-
snapdragon_crypt
commented
there's no if, and, or but theft is theft and is honestly insulting to all creators.
any creator would've been happy to have been made a new one contest, commission, or etc. there's no excuse for shame :( -
thejexxmixx
commented
Ai Art isn't art. Keep that the **** away from twitch. Period.
-
MoonfireScythe
commented
AI Art is not art! It's theft! Please be supportive to art created by human beings and their own efforts to create, AI pieces have no business being in the same space.