Twitch category name collision
Currently two (or more) games with the exact same name (usually reboots) share the same category in Twitch. And all the cover art, description, tags are taken from only one of the games. This usually means that the other game(s) effectively completely lacks a page on twitch, despite being a completely different game and having unique gameplay. Can something be done about this?
-
Ultra_Dreadnought
commented
Dwarf Fortress (2006), Dwarf Fortress (2022) and Dwarf Fortress Adventure Mode (2024) are updates of the same game rather than separate games.
-
myk002
commented
This bifurcation is also affecting the metrics on SteamDB. Please merge!
-
Droviin
commented
I've heard it's a remaster, but it's not. It's sequential adjustments. Twitch seems to be playing favorites by not creating different categories for every patch in a game, or seem to understand long dev cycles.
-
dvildawn
commented
DF community is small enough as it is, don't split up the community further. This issue must be fixed.
-
kramptonking
commented
Dwarf Fortress has had 50 different versions because it's a game that has been in development for over 20 years. The idea of splitting this small community two ways makes as much sense as splitting it 50 different ways and this mistake should be reversed ASAP.
-
clinodev
commented
Thousands of people might well think no one at all streams DF, which is a shame. Please merge the categories!
-
KitfoxGames
commented
I'm Alexandra, the Community Manager for Kitfox Games and the publishers of Dwarf Fortress. Our community brought it to our attention that there are two entries for Dwarf Fortress.
This is causing confusion from our streamers and viewers as everyone streams to the original category but the other category uses the up-to-date cover art. Is there a way we can combine these two entries?
I contacted support and they told me to post here.
Thank you in advance for your help in this matter!
-
Tarogato
commented
Leaving a comment in hope that it helps.
I wanted to stream some Wipeout speedruns, but there's three unrelated games by that name and the one I play doesn't even appear as an option to choose because it's overridden by a game nobody has probably ever streamed.
-
LesleyPro_04
commented
This is definitely confusing as the GBA version uses Young Link's voice from Ocarina of Time/Majora's Mask while the SNES version doesn't use a voice for Link at all.
-
stephen_irl
commented
more specifically, the GBA version should point to https://www.igdb.com/games/the-legend-of-zelda-a-link-to-the-past-and-four-swords for accuracy, which would also eliminate any confusion. I've submitted change 2049304 to the IGDB website to request this.
-
PonPonTheDreambunny
commented
It appears that categories are manually adjusted as they are reported in the comments. So here's my suggestion.
The games of Spyro Reignited Trilogy has been split from the originals, but the names are the same, forcing you to pick based on the cover alone. Adding the suffix " - Reignited" makes this clear. None of the three games have localised titles, so just taking the default title and using it for all regions should be fine.
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/spyro-the-dragon-reignited
"Spyro the Dragon" -> "Spyro the Dragon - Reignited"
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/spyro-2-riptos-rage-reignited
"Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage!" -> "Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage! - Reignited"
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/spyro-year-of-the-dragon-reignited
"Spyro: Year of the Dragon" -> "Spyro: Year of the Dragon - Reignited"The same can be done with Crash Bandicoot: N. Sane Trilogy. The titles are again not localised so all regions use the same titles.
The first game of the remaster is missing on Twitch, but the IGDB entry is https://www.igdb.com/games/crash-bandicoot--2
"Crash Bandicoot" -> "Crash Bandicoot - N. Sane Trilogy"
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/crash-bandicoot-2-cortex-strikes-back-2017
"Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back" -> "Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back - N. Sane Trilogy"
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/crash-bandicoot-warped-2017
"Crash Bandicoot: Warped" -> "Crash Bandicoot: Warped - N. Sane Trilogy"I suggest using "-" as the separator for the suffix even for the first game of both franchises for the sake of consistency, and to hint more at that it's the remake of the first game, and not the trilogy itself as a package.
-
LuizMiguel
commented
When choosing Mega Man X category on Twitch, it changes to another with the same name in the VODs. It is also messed up when you try to find someone playing the game.
This is the original category: https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/mega-man-x
https://www.igdb.com/games/mega-man-x/And this is what is showing in the VODs (and there is no way to change it): https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/mega-man-x-1
https://www.igdb.com/games/mega-man-x--2/Looks like this category is a port of Mega Man X to Genesis/Mega Drive, according to IGBD.
-
Experiment_Lain
commented
Sigil II just came out as a new episode for DOOM 1993 by John Romero. I am streaming from the right category in OBS, but Twitch displays the wrong game. There are FOUR separate entries for DOOM 2016 on Twitch now, and NONE For DOOM 1993. This is NOT Ultimate DOOM.
dandymcgee commented · July 10, 2023 9:39 PM ·
In the "Edit Stream Info" modual, when I try to set my category to the original DOOM game by typing "doom" in the input box and selecting the *second* item in the dropdown list, it ignores my selection and picks the first entry, which is also titled "DOOM" and refers to the 2016 version of the game. This causes my stream category to have the wrong image and reference the wrong game. Please make the dropdown honor my selection, and don't just pick the first string in the list that happens to match what I clicked. I clicked the second item for a reason, and want that as my category! -_- There is no known workaround to this bug.
-
Spleebie
commented
There are two separate categories for The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past, one for the SNES game and one for the GBA game. This has been a problem since IGDB separated the GBA game out into two separate games with a parent bundle, and until recent months both linked to the same game page on IGDB. They are now separate, but have the exact same game name and artwork. I posted on IGDB's discord but they were unwilling to change either, causing twitch streamers to accidentally select the wrong category. Please add year or platform to the category selection to distinguish these.
-
Radgryd
commented
They're on the brink of fixing this, but some IGDB links are still wrong, and that's where it breaks again.
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/tomb-raider-1 needs to link to https://www.igdb.com/games/tomb-raider, not to https://www.igdb.com/games/tomb-raider--4/.
-
GMP__
commented
@ponponthebonbon I have been suggesting this for years to no avail. Funnily enough, the URL for user profiles in this very website seems to follow this exact same pattern of <id>-<name>, lol.
-
PonPonTheDreambunny
commented
I had the idea before, but a much better idea for Twitch is just adding the ID from IGDB ... because my idea of adding the year will cause links to break if the year changes (when more info comes out).
Take the idea from how UserVoice has the ID of the post and category before the name in the URL.
Using the suggestion from before, using Sonic the Hedgeghog, you will get:
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/3192-Sonic%20the%20Hedgehog (the original, ID: 3192)
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/88912-Sonic%20the%20Hedgehog (the remaster, ID: 88912)
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/6231-Sonic%20the%20Hedgehog (the 2006-version, ID: 6231)
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/198248-Sonic%20the%20Hedgehog (the ad for the film, ID: 198248)
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/207208-Sonic%20the%20Hedgehog (the C64-port, ID: 207208)The IDs on IGDB are very uneven in length, but it ensures that the game has a unique URL that never changes, and can be applied to all categories across Twitch, without having to do a case-by-case basis.
---
When searching for a category, the year is not listead, but including that would help a lot as well. I think it would also help a lot if consoles were listed instead of the number of followers and watchers of the category, personally at least.
So typing "Sonic the Hedgehog" would give:
Sonic the Hedgehog (1991)
GEN • X360 • iOS • Wii • Win • PS3Sonic the Hedgehog (2013)
And • XONE • PS4 • iOS • PS5 • Win • NS • XSXSonic the Hedgehog (2006)
X360 • PS3 • WiiSonic the Hedgehog (2020)
iOS • Web • AndSonic the Hedgehog (2021)
C64Some notes would be if there's a port, it has a separate ID on IGDB but isn't included as a separate entry on Twitch, and could be merged with the category, which is the case of Sonic the Hedgehog (2006) ID 6231, and the Wii-port ID 264886 (which was cancelled, which Twitch could take into consideration too). But then also the abbreviations must sometimes take languages into consideration, such as "GEN" would be for en-US only, but "SMD" for every other language.
-
akoluthic
commented
Are there two different issues here? The OP mentions two games being combined into a single category so you literally can't find one of them. There's another problem, which might be related, where two games with the same name each have their own category (and page), but when you try to select one of them as your "Category" when editing your stream info, it ends up selecting the other one with the same name.
You can see this with the name "Graviton" mentioned in an earlier post. If you edit your Stream Info category and select the Graviton with box art (not the gray placeholder art), it will actually select the one with placeholder art, which is the wrong game.
-
GaybitBiscuit
commented
Overgrowth (2017) gets overriden no matter what by Overgrowth (2018)
Night Watch (2005) gets overriden no matter what by Night Watch (2020)In both cases it's a completely different game by a different developer.
And in both cases there's no workaround to select the correct category. -
Mello42
commented
Had this problem with our game, Saturnalia. It seems like they were separated into:
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/saturnalia-2022/
and
https://www.twitch.tv/directory/category/saturnalia/
Although for some reason I cannot seem to be able to follow the 2022 version.