Please stop messing with our muscle memory and revert the UI change
Twitch just rolled out a change on the PC browser website that moves the panel that contains the streamer's username, stream title/category, follow button, concurrent viewers,... to the top of the stream, which not only messes with our muscle memory but also makes the experience a bit less pleasant as the stream got pushed downwards from its original centered position.
Please Twitch, if it ain't broke don't try to fix it.
-
1UpJohn
commented
I hate this. At least give us an option to change it back.
-
tinyhaggis
commented
This change literally makes my brain hurt. Please revert it back to the way it was before. Every single site that has video has the information BELOW it. Also, you've now moved 6 different features/parts of the UI so that scrolling even a little causes the bar to disappear. What a bunch of numpties. You also made the video area SMALLER. Isn't this supposed to be a video streaming platform where people come to, you know, watch video?
-
harvelein
commented
I refuse to believe this is a active decision that was made and not some annoying bug.
-
thi_avatar
commented
Please stop incompetently making useless and inept changes, and instead focus on fixing the ongoing flaws in the platform.
-
Tolrin
commented
Among other downsides, this change reduces the size of the video player on my screen. The primary reason I use twitch is, surprise, watching the video, so reducing the size of the player by increasing website clutter negatively impacts my viewing experience. I would definitely like an opt out option, or just a reversion of this UI change.
-
samurai_xington
commented
please let us change it back at least
-
swanrunner
commented
at least give us a toggle to change it back
-
soggyburrito
commented
This seems like a change implemented by someone who has no experience with UI/UX. No other video content platform arranges their layout like this. It's just unintuitive. I don't really understand the point.
-
Ilktheman
commented
The new UI is unnecessary, I can understand wanting to switch things around, but if you are going to change a few things, you might as well change the entirety of it. WHat I mean by this is that Twitch selectively changed the position of the username, stream title, timer, and tags, leaving an empty space underneath the video. Now moving all of these items above the stream not only looks weird but also will cut off certain elements like the tags and add in a drop-down, resulting with the video being cut off slightly. It depends on the amount of tags the streamer has, and since most streamers want to up their views, they add a lot of tags to draw in more viewers. So with the empty space, it leaves a feel as if something should replace it, like moving the "About" section up to fill in the space.
The other issue I have with this is that in terms of organization, moving the previously mentioned elements away from everything else feels broken. The streamer video is the main focus, which is why it's above everything else. Then, you can find all the other information down below in one flow. Now you have it set as Information ---> Stream---> information. This flow does not make sense.
Please change it back, the original design was not broken and it had no errors, so why change it?
-
theremin2014
commented
It's awkward and doesn't improve anything. Change for the sake of change ads no value.... Change it back.
-
bcmurray75
commented
I also have found myself part of this experiment. It is just awful. Having the title bar at the top just feels completely out of place. The implementation is a mess. There is not enough space for all information. For some streams part of the title is cut off or even worse the follow button, number of viewers, and time is missing.
It makes so much more sense for the title to naturally flow into the About.
-
Rempler
commented
Shirley there are just monkey in the UI change team and see: "I wonder what this button will do..."
-
devastator2161
commented
How is Twitch still in existence after losing money for a decade? Amazon needs to clean house, since you are all clearly incompetent. Even kindergarteners would have executed a better UI change. What is your CEO even doing?
-
LoLoTheWarPigeon
commented
Whomever came up with this change should not have any control over design. This is a horrible UI modification that makes the screen feel more cluttered.
-
KoppdasOriginal
commented
I honestly see no reason for the change, it has been good all the years, everyone is used to it and it jsut feels wrong for now. There were some more detailed answered why its even worse on reddit about it:
* It breaks up the "text data blocks" (used to be video-text, now it is text-video-text)
* It forces your eye down further on screen, this makes pinned notes/polls/hype trains and such easier to miss (or rather, increases cognitive load to scan for them)
* it puts a "moving object" (the stream timer) in a space that usually is static, this just increases cognitive load
* It cuts longer stream titles / hides stream tags (unless you actively click the "down arrow")
* It causes a huge dead space below the video (to the left of the sub management stuff) that could be better used to increase information density by doing - hear me out - putting the stream title and tags there...
* And who tought it was a good idea to have "follow" (now above) and "sub" (still below) on either side of the video instead of next to each other? You even broke up a logical grouping?! -
DocoNord
commented
Please stop trying to fix things. Work on Mobile optimization. This is getting ridiculously out of hand
-
Witchfynder_Finder
commented
Hate this change. No reason for it.
-
MiVa_
commented
revert the UI change, top channel info bar is bad
-
chewdi
commented
Please change it back, the UI is not intuitive. If the title is long, the user has to click the dropdown just to read the full title as opposed to minimal scrolling. This is not a positive change.
-
zabbatheartist
commented
Are you trying to get kick to overtake you?