Better vetting/reporting when it comes to ads that can cause epilepsy
As someone with epilepsy I've lost count of the amount of ads that have left me unwell or even outright caused a seizure. The latest pokemon x marshmallow ad is ATROCIOUS for this.
But when it came time to report the ad to twitch I was told there WAS no way to report it outside of the EU, and contacting twitch was confusing ust sent me to user feedback.
There NEEDS to be either better vetting on these ads or a way to report them easily as they are happening, no matter where you are in the world.
For people with epilepsy. there's no way of knowing how bad your next seizure is going to be - and that each seizure could, sadly, be your last. I'm asking, politely, to be met halfway with the bare minimum of accessibility for people with a disability that can prove fatal.
Allow us to report ads for health concerns, and either block ads that cause it or vet your ads better.
Or add a tagging system to ads that allows people to customize what ads show.
-
NotOldMaxLevel
commented
This is, from a legal standpoint, extreme reckless disregard at the least, and willful damage at the most. I look forward to observing the potential legal fallout of a platform knowingly causing harm.
-
QueenoftheScribes
commented
Ridiculous! Shape the **** up! You're apart of a disgustingly rich company, you have ZERO EXCUSE.
-
Mayhem_Mudkip
commented
This is ridiculous. "Don't run stuff that could cause seizures" has been a settled matter and common sense ever since, ironically enough, the Pokemon Seizure Incident 30 years ago.
Twitch, fix this and at least have the decency to be embarrassed that you failed this very simple hurdle.
-
zappshot
commented
If ads are going to be forced to be shown to people by default, there should be vetting to ensure that they don't harm the end user, plain and simple.
If you can't ensure that your end users will be safe and not medically harmed, you have no right to be running ads in the first place.
The fact that I have heard *more than 5* instances of people suffering seizures because of ads that Twitch has run is frankly dangerous and negligent, especially since there is no way to accurately report ads for being overly flashy. There's guidelines for things as small as emotes to ensure that they're not harmful in the same manner, why are advertisers not held to the same standard?
-
RyuFlynn
commented
That's so stupid that this is even an issue! It's not a new medical issue by any shot so you would think it would be basic knowledge, especially in a media environment in an era where most people on the planet are watching stuff on screens. Do Better twitch!
-
Omonora
commented
Yeah, this needs to be addressed. Twitch, please do better!
-
anathemadrian
commented
It is truly ludicrous that this isn't already considered by Twitch. This is very basic stuff.
-
HinaHaze
commented
It is ridiculous that, for as long as I can remember there have been epilepsy warnings at the begining of moves and shows. And somehow we have disregarded this learning for adds on twitch...
There should be a way for us to flag unsafe adds. And there should be consequences for those making add that will cost people their lives.
Please Twitch, do better. -
MaryTheSassyLopunny
commented
Given that other forms of media are required to disclose if flashing images are used in them, the fact that this is even happening is atrocious.
People's lives are not something to be disregarded for the sake of some advertisements.
-
foxwaystreams
commented
110% agreed. People's lives matter more than some ****** flashy advertisements
-
BunCoven
commented
I second banning ads that pose a health risk to users as ads have no way to warn users they are coming, there's no reason for an unsuspecting user to suddenly have a epilepsy inducing advertisement play without warning
and what if a user doesn't even realize they have epilepsy, it would be awful for someone to die because they got effected with an ad like that
even the option to just opt into having audio only ads, there needs to be SOMETHING done to keep the health of twitch users in mind besides just waiting for something to happen and going "oops, we'll do better next time"
-
Ashezth
commented
Lemme dig your ear for this one, pokemon pulled an episode 30 years ago for inducing epileptic problems in thousands of kids after it aired one time.
How often are these ads being played? How many people are you affecting with your negligence? Do better Twitch. We expect better. -
RhinoSCE
commented
Absolutely agree with this. There should be a much more done to prevent people who suffer from epilepsy having to suffer because of any advertising twitch shows during an ad break. The same goes to any other potential health issue that could start from visual or even audio.
To put it simply, fix your adverts, Twitch.
-
EspenVT
commented
As a platform that speaks constantly on it's accessibility to the world and diverse audiences it serves, to continue to allow ads and content in direct aggression to underlying conditions of said audience can only be labeled as deliberate, careless, and abhorrent lunacy. Walk the walk, Twitch.
-
raikarottwow
commented
Protect people with epilepsy, ads with flashing lights are not helpful in the slightest and totally unnecassary, everyone deserves to feel safe. Your pockets are not more important then your streamers health twitch
-
Banezarian
commented
I personally have had multiple ads run in the past while I was watching that I've had to look away from because they activated my flash fatigue. While I did try to report them, they still never went away until they stopped being advertised. We genuinely need better control over what ads can be displayed as streamers, and what ads can be viewed as viewers.
-
StargazerKG
commented
This is going to drive people to look into getting ad blockers, because as much as everyone hates ads, they will NOT abide ads that can trigger seizures.
-
GrayGooGlitch
commented
The ad system as it exists doesnt allow for us to have any say in what runs. I can understand from a content perspective, but when its something that can be legitimately hazardous to our communities, it crosses a line.
-
snowytasha_
commented
The fact that Twitch doesn't let streamers control what ads get ran on their channel is disgraceful enough, the fact that there are ads that can cause actual harm to people is extra bad. Ads with that can cause epileptic seizures should not be allowed to run at all on any service. Do better for your disabled users, Twitch.
-
BrodoKamen
commented
For the love of Gog, please put an epilepsy warning of SOME KIND in front of those ads instead of just letting them play and possibly cause damage to some people. It's not that hard to comprehend.