Replace AI-Generated Category Images with Human Made Work
For the creative/non-gaming categories, ESPECIALLY the art category, please replace the AI generated category images with credited, human-made images.
We've had the old category images for a while, they definitely could have used an overhaul. With the hiring and crediting of emote artists for new hype train emotes, some of us were cautiously optimistic that new category images would follow the same pattern. Twitch has a thriving creative community and it's no secret that many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. Many of us have had our work stolen with this technology.
Regardless of Twitch's view on the use of these technologies, the creative community as a whole has an overwhelmingly negative view on it—see the previous UserVoice to remove the Catinthechat emote with almost 14,000 upvotes here https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/928738-badges-emotes/suggestions/49188362-no-ai-for-global-emotes-change-catinthechat, as well as the hundreds of artists who came together to create new cats that could have easily been used for the emote. Moon worded it well in the UserVoice on the AI generated cat icons: "Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform."
Even the non-creative community seems upset at their images being AI image generations: https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/934332-customer-experience/suggestions/49173698-fix-the-ai-gerneated-category-image.
With this in mind, we ask that Twitch reconsider representing us, a community who OVERWHELMINGLY disapprove of the use of AI, with AI generated imagery that they could have instead asked one of the MANY creatives on Twitch to do. The 'Artists + Makers' creator club is full of multi-disciplined, highly creative, and very skilled folks who would be happy to take on the challenge of helping to remake not just the Art category, but all of the AI generated category images. Because, quite frankly—even with AI taken out of the picture—the new category images do not feel well representative of the groups they are supposed to be representing. For example, the Art category image captures only a sliver of the community it is supposed to represent, fine artists. It is a vibrant place filled with artists of every medium and genre! This image does not represent us well. Feel free to reach out to the members of your creator club for ideas, iteration, design, and work. We WANT Twitch to feel like home for us. We WANT to create and engage with the community. We do not want to be disregarded.
Please take advantage of the creativity and passion of your currently thriving creative community, instead of taking actions that at best read out of touch and careless towards them. If creatives feel like the platform is actively hostile towards them, that thriving community will start to dwindle. Don't do that to us.
-
reclusive_fox_
commented
Ai art isn't art, it's stealing bits and pieces from hard working artists and piecing it together. It just seems like your using AI to be lazy even through your a ******* company
-
SlightlyMoistMilkBread
commented
Using AI for the art category is just straight up disrespectful to the thousands of artists that use this platform to share their HUMAN creativity. Twitch is actively stealing from those artist by using generative AI slop and not only that they are expressing how cheap they are by being unwilling to hire one of the thousands of artists. Poor, sloppy, and gross behavior Twitch. Do better.
-
SetToBuild
commented
This is incredibly disrespectful to every artist on the platform. Create, don't generate!
-
Gloomira
commented
WE DONT WANT AI ART HERE !!!!
-
ArtofGaby
commented
Please, you all have so many artist at your disposal why slap them in the face by using Ai. Gaming is art, EVERYTHING is possible bc of the love and passion of millions of artist for the entirety of human history. So give it the respect it deserves.
-
daodave1982
commented
I think AI is interfering and butting in where it shouldn’t be. It takes work away from hardworking artists, it’s all very unfair
-
himelikestea
commented
When I see genAI images, it makes me conclude that the people behind it are morally bankrupt and has extremely bad taste. And I immediately stop supporting or engaging with anything they do.
-
diggitydawgdiggity
commented
Just straight up gross
-
WarAnvil_WasTaken
commented
There's especially no excuse for using AI in terms of any artistic endeavor. GenAI is just something CEOs and shareholders have started to treasure a whole lot more than actual creative talent, and I pray that the bubble for such bursts real soon. Please bring back the previous category banners, or at least allow someone to draw new banners!
-
TantalusStudios
commented
Not only is there distaste in the association by principle, but it will irrevocably implant the question into each streamer's mind "is MY content being used to generate AI?" Particulary for artists who like to stream their progress and workflow. Whether directly used or not, it will place doubts and drive away many who would have otherwise been great additions.
-
BlackSapphy
commented
I do not support any sort of AI use- ESPECIALLY when trying to represent a Creative Community. These are made of people who are proud of their work, and proud that it is human-made. Using AI, something that is near unanimously HATED by those communities for NUMEROUS and VERY legitimate reasons, to represent them is an insult at best. More accurately: It’s disgustingly dismissive and unethical.
Get someone to make the images you need. It’s not hard, and it will be better than whatever mess an AI will spit out, and on the business side: look better PR-wise anyway due to the high number of creatives that use your platform.
-
crashitcolors
commented
I do not respect twitch openly using AI generated slop instead of utilizing art from various creators that are already present in this community .
-
EmmeTheOdd
commented
Get it together, Twitch. No one wants this.
-
SpookyRahl
commented
GenAI is trained on stolen art. For a platform that tons of artists use, using GenAI to make images you could easily pay an artist to make is gross. Reconsider this immediately.
-
dremoranightmares
commented
Absolutely despicable to already squeeze creators bone dry for every bit of value they create for you and THEN decide to devalue artists' work even more and use GenAI instead of hiring artists to create for you! Absolutely shameful! How do you people even look at yourselves in the mirror?!
-
FoxpirateAce
commented
The fact that Twitch can hire real human talent and trade, yet refuses and uses stolen slop imagery of that very community of creatives, is very telling of who they are as a company. They don't care about the creatives and communities that build their site, just the money they get from them. Its disgusting and as a creative that uses the platform on occasion, their actions certainly make me think twice about being here. I've dropped major platforms before and I won't blink to do it with Twitch either.
-
LeviAMeade
commented
Please just use human artists instead of AI. It’s better for our economy, it looks better, and it’s much more environmentally stable.
-
EchoRemmington
commented
Generative "AI" - better classified as large language models (LLMs) - are based on the theft of intellectual property. Training them on only things found in the public domain is impossible - LLMs require much more data than that. Compensating people for the work that these data sets are trained on is also unfeasible financially. To make any profit, plagiarism is the only answer, and profit is all that the people making these LLMs care about; that is the core of capitalist endeavours.
Rather than being a tool to raise up people that some laud it to be, it is used by those with financial means to further disenfranchise those who rely upon them to make enough money to live in our capitalist society. Even without the plagiarism at the heart of this technology, we do not have the social safety nets required to keep people housed and fed when corporations use LLMs. They care about their bottom line - not who they hurt or even kill in the process.
Daniel Clancy, the CEO of Twitch, does not disclose his own salary. In an interview for Dexerto published on 26 March, 2024, he is quoted as saying, "There are tons of jobs I could have taken to make more money. That isn’t what was motivating me to come to Twitch [and] I think the tech space is inflated salaries and there are some companies that just pay you silly amounts of money." The article also purports that Clancy "revealed that some of the platform’s biggest names are making a lot more money than he currently does."
Via Comparably, "The average Twitch executive compensation is $210,781 a year.The median estimated compensation for executives at Twitch including base salary and bonus is $203,241, or $97 per hour. At Twitch, the most compensated executive makes $427,000, annually, and the lowest compensated makes $65,000.
"52 employees at Twitch rank their Compensation in the Top 50% of similar sized companies on Comparably (based on 159 ratings) while 48 employees at Twitch rank their Perks And Benefits in the Top 25% of similar sized companies on Comparably (based on 52 ratings)."
Forbes calculated the average salary in the USA as being $59,428 in the USA, where Twitch is based.
To see Twitch, which says that it holds itself to a certain standard, use LLMs this way is troubling. It signals that they too only care about their bottom line. I understand that Twitch is ultimately a business, but it does not need to be complicit in moral bankruptcy to keep itself from running out of money. What it needs to do is support the people who allow it to exist by choosing it to stream. The top earners on the site are a tiny fraction of the streaming ecosystem - the vast majority of those who stream content essentially do so for free. Streamers invest in Twitch by virtue of using it, as do viewers, and the company needs to reciprocate that investment in order to retain them.
Outside of all of this is, of course, the environmental impact of LLMs, as well as the countless people who actually put in the hours to train them. From a TIME article published 18 January 2023, titled "OpenAI Used Kenyan Workers on Less Than $2 Per Hour to Make ChatGPT Less Toxic":
"ChatGPT’s predecessor, GPT-3 [...] was a difficult sell, as the app was also prone to blurting out violent, sexist and racist remarks." The solution? "OpenAI sent tens of thousands of snippets of text to an outsourcing firm in Kenya[.] Much of that text appeared to have been pulled from the darkest recesses of the internet. Some of it described situations in graphic detail like child sexual abuse, **********, murder, suicide, torture, self harm, and incest." Real humans were forced to sift through text and, indeed, images containing things which can easily haunt someone for life.
In short: the human cost of LLMs is incalculable. Twitch aligning itself with this technology does not instill faith in the direction it is taking as a company.
-
ElyseExplosion
commented
We know you can hire artists. Why not... continue to do that instead of having the soulless pollution machine do it?
-
doc2pan
commented
This latest move, especially after the flack Twitch has received from the CatInTheChat and other AIGen emotes, sickens me to my very core. I already made a promise to myself that I would never buy Twitch subs and bits again due to Twitch’s horrible mismanagement, false suspensions/bans against vtubers, and for what Twitch staff did to DokiBird during the Twitch Rivals tournament of 2024. This latest move has me seriously considering never streaming on Twitch again. Even if I continue streaming on this platform, I will be strictly prioritizing off platform monetization via Patreon and other non-Twitch affiliated platforms. The prices Twitch has set for the basic Tier1 sub, on top of Twitch’s constant insults to their user base’s intelligence, are completely asinine with what little Twitch provides the streamer community that is not in the top 1%.
Twitch, whether you know this or not, you still need us smaller streamers. While you may be getting hundreds of thousands, millions even, from the top streamers on your platform, all of the smaller streamers combined provide you with equal or greater revenue. There’s a vast majority of us not in the partner program, and even many who are, that are disgusted by your blatant disrespect of creators and those who worked so hard to make your platform last as long as it has. If you choose to keep going down this route, you will lose all of our support entirely and we will migrate elsewhere. Just like many people left X (formerly Twitter) to move to Bluesky and made Bluesky as successful as they are at this current moment, we will do the same to you once the next best option pops up. Things are already rocky and we all know all too well that Twitch hasn’t been able to pull themselves out of the negatives for some time. Imagine what it would be like when everyone’s gone and how fast the already negative profits will plummet beyond return.
What will it be, Twitch? Remove the AIGen emotes, as well as the AIGen category thumbnails, and start providing the bare minimum services that you promised your creators. Or keep screwing us creators over, resulting in a vast majority of us to leave and build up a direct competitor, causing your business to perish.