Skip to content
Translate Ideas and Comments
Choose language:
There was an error during translation

Settings and activity

1 result found

  1. 7,985 votes

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    How important is this to you?

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)
    An error occurred while saving the comment
    EchoRemmington commented  · 

    Generative "AI" - better classified as large language models (LLMs) - are based on the theft of intellectual property. Training them on only things found in the public domain is impossible - LLMs require much more data than that. Compensating people for the work that these data sets are trained on is also unfeasible financially. To make any profit, plagiarism is the only answer, and profit is all that the people making these LLMs care about; that is the core of capitalist endeavours.

    Rather than being a tool to raise up people that some laud it to be, it is used by those with financial means to further disenfranchise those who rely upon them to make enough money to live in our capitalist society. Even without the plagiarism at the heart of this technology, we do not have the social safety nets required to keep people housed and fed when corporations use LLMs. They care about their bottom line - not who they hurt or even kill in the process.

    Daniel Clancy, the CEO of Twitch, does not disclose his own salary. In an interview for Dexerto published on 26 March, 2024, he is quoted as saying, "There are tons of jobs I could have taken to make more money. That isn’t what was motivating me to come to Twitch [and] I think the tech space is inflated salaries and there are some companies that just pay you silly amounts of money." The article also purports that Clancy "revealed that some of the platform’s biggest names are making a lot more money than he currently does."

    Via Comparably, "The average Twitch executive compensation is $210,781 a year.The median estimated compensation for executives at Twitch including base salary and bonus is $203,241, or $97 per hour. At Twitch, the most compensated executive makes $427,000, annually, and the lowest compensated makes $65,000.

    "52 employees at Twitch rank their Compensation in the Top 50% of similar sized companies on Comparably (based on 159 ratings) while 48 employees at Twitch rank their Perks And Benefits in the Top 25% of similar sized companies on Comparably (based on 52 ratings)."

    Forbes calculated the average salary in the USA as being $59,428 in the USA, where Twitch is based.

    To see Twitch, which says that it holds itself to a certain standard, use LLMs this way is troubling. It signals that they too only care about their bottom line. I understand that Twitch is ultimately a business, but it does not need to be complicit in moral bankruptcy to keep itself from running out of money. What it needs to do is support the people who allow it to exist by choosing it to stream. The top earners on the site are a tiny fraction of the streaming ecosystem - the vast majority of those who stream content essentially do so for free. Streamers invest in Twitch by virtue of using it, as do viewers, and the company needs to reciprocate that investment in order to retain them.

    Outside of all of this is, of course, the environmental impact of LLMs, as well as the countless people who actually put in the hours to train them. From a TIME article published 18 January 2023, titled "OpenAI Used Kenyan Workers on Less Than $2 Per Hour to Make ChatGPT Less Toxic":

    "ChatGPT’s predecessor, GPT-3 [...] was a difficult sell, as the app was also prone to blurting out violent, sexist and racist remarks." The solution? "OpenAI sent tens of thousands of snippets of text to an outsourcing firm in Kenya[.] Much of that text appeared to have been pulled from the darkest recesses of the internet. Some of it described situations in graphic detail like child sexual abuse, **********, murder, suicide, torture, self harm, and incest." Real humans were forced to sift through text and, indeed, images containing things which can easily haunt someone for life.

    In short: the human cost of LLMs is incalculable. Twitch aligning itself with this technology does not instill faith in the direction it is taking as a company.