Change the LUL emote to not be a transphobic, sexist gamer
The LUL emote is currently a picture of TotalBiscuit, who rose to fame as part of the harassment campaign against both cis and trans women known as GamerGate. TB has, among other things, told a trans woman to go die of cancer. While reality has a nice sense of irony and TB himself died of cancer back in 2018, his sexist legacy lives on in the form of Twitch putting him on the front page of the emotes list for everyone to see, including people like myself who have been on the receiving end of his cult following who literally worked with open Nazis and TERFs to harass me off various social media platforms.
There's no reason to subject trans people to such an iconic sexist transphobe on a regular basis. Twitch changed the pogchamp emoji after finding out the guy was a fascist, so why can't they do the same for LUL? Why do women across the platform have to put up with this?
-
Britsilov
commented
Thank goodness he's dead, now kill his sexist legacy pls.
-
JMcAfreak
commented
TotalBiscuit was many things. A transphobe and a sexist he was not. He was painted as such despite his many words and actions to the contrary. He has defended the trans community many times over, including openly and at length expressing disgust at the "Are Traps Gay" question that was asked of Jesse Cox at a panel. Nothing in his history of statements, videos, interviews, or words, denotes him as a transphobe or a sexist.
TotalBiscuit DID NOT rise to fame for his support of GamerGate. His support of GamerGate was also STRICTLY on the grounds and belief that they were advocating for what they said they were advocating for: ethics in journalism. Game Journalistic ethics had been a pet cause of his for a long time before that. He, like many others in the movement (many of whom now denounce it if they are not right wing), had been fooled into an idea of the movement that just wasn't true. While there were sweeping elements of GamerGate that did harass women, he was a VOCAL opponent of said harassment. In an interview with David Pakman on the subject, he spoke at length about how he believed a group of trolls had hijacked and come to represent what people saw as GamerGate, and how he believed the fight had devolved into two armies fighting two wars on two different battlefields against two different enemies because of those trolls. He wanted no part in the harassment, and he made that ABUNDANTLY clear. He literally just wanted ethics in games journalism, a cause which he had been championing for quite some time before that. His support of GamerGate was ONLY on the premise that that's what it was actually about. If there ever was someone who truly believed that GG was only about ethics in games journalism, it was TotalBiscuit.
Many of the prominent figureheads of GG went right and became Trump supporters, such as Sargon and others (some, such as Milo Yiannopoulos, were already Trump supporters). TotalBiscuit was not one of them, and he drew intense mockery and harassment from the now-right wing GG supporters when he expressed his open and unwavering disgust that Trump had won the election (partially due to the harm it would do to women and trans folks). He and plenty of others who had supported GamerGate for its stated purpose (and not the actual purpose) either stayed left leaning or went further left when they realized the movement had been hijacked by the right. His staunch unwillingness to move Right-wing painted a target on his back by the very people who had been singing his praises during GamerGate. His support (and defense) of trans people, even when it was unpopular to do so, drew plenty of ire from people, fueled by right wing figureheads who HAD risen to fame as a result of GG.
Let's stop this slander, be it mistaken (which I believe it is) or outright malicious. GamerGate is a stain on his resume, sure. But he has done so many things to demonstrate that he did not support harassment of women or trans folks, and to the contrary, was willing to defend trans people from harm.
-
nyrhalahotep
commented
There's nothing worse than a bloke who's openly, proudly, and joyfully dating a Trans Woman finding out I'm unknowingly perpetuating the willful ignorance and gaslit hatred of such a vile ideology.
My Girlfriend, and nearly every Trans and Enby person I've met have been the best people, kind, empathetic, accepting, clever, funny and selfless.
Let's protect them, and start to evolve beyond the ignorance. -
papa_pudding
commented
LUL
-
the_boops_
commented
Twitch is here for everyone and if anyone feels unsafe then this whole platform is unstable. We need to start with the smallest streams by making them feel safe. Revenue will come in spades, don't worry, Twitch.
-
FaeAlicia
commented
Oh, please. No one's wondering why Twitch hasn't removed the emote yet. We all saw the Twitch leak that showed the top 100 streamers only having one woman in it. Twitch heavily prefers cishet white patriarchy and only removed pogchamp because the guy was blatantly racist at a time when racist people were actually facing even the smallest of consequences.
The smear campaign is all these dudebros coming in here and defending the guy who became famous for telling women to go die of cancer - all in a desperate attempt to avoid having women on the platform.
-
jebus3211
commented
For everyone wondering why this hasn't been removed. it's because this is yet another attempt at slandering a dead man who cannot defend himself.
This emote should without a doubt stay, to remind everyone of what a kind loving and gentle man John was. his legacy remains strong to this day despite the hit pieces and slander
-
sqidaedir
commented
I see a lot of comments rushing to defend not just TotalBiscuit, but even his support for Gamer Gate. Which was/is an on going harassment campaign from which sexism and bigotry is normalized and celebrated that he participated in.
I find it ironic how even todays "Noah Time" he directly references the unbelievable ignorance and a lot of "gamer gaters" try to twist it into some kind of gaming ethics and journalism when it has been so much more.... (for reference https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbD-sS83Yi0&t=198s)
Demanding facts of a well known issue, and an open supporter means that you would rather defend horrible actions over premise than listen to victims.
The worst part is how people will hide behind cancer as a means to further excuse any of the claims.
Twitch should let the emote die out, and not prop up anyone, let alone gamer gate supporters like Total Biscuit.
-
parker021597
commented
The comments by OP here really make me doubt the validity of their claims, tbh. It reads like the guy (who has been dead for years due to cancer, mind you) said something to them on Twitter one time and they have held a major grudge since. Seeing as there's zero context given or proof shown of the harassment alleged, I'm inclined to believe there's more to this story than the OP would like to have us believe and have major trouble taking it seriously as a result. The simple fact they're taking a cheap victory lap over the "irony" of someone literally dying also just comes across as incredibly mean-spirited and harms their standing as someone with good intentions.
There's also a certain irony in how many replies here had no idea who was even in the emote until this was posted. The OP is legitimately triggering more anxieties than any amount of LUL spam could ever accomplish, and upsetting people over something that really isn't a reality at all.
-
mondoth
commented
It's crazy to see so many people in this comment section ready to just accept this fabricated slander by wingnuts.
No, TB was not sexist or transphobic.. these are just buzzword weaponized by a petty, vitriol and manipulative person.And Gamergate did not start as a harassment campaign, despite what left-wingnut propaganda wants people to believe.
Gamergate started as a stance against corruption in gaming journalism and competitions, and the resulting demand for disclosure and ethics reform. related to cases and accusations of corruption in those topics. And that's exactly the reason why Totalbiscuit was formerly behind the gamergate movement, it had nothing to do with being a "sexist" or "transphobe".
However some loud extremes turned Twitter into cesspool of insults and rage (like twitter always does).
Cerrain gaming journalists then slandered and generalized all people that used Gamergate as "misogynist white nerds", which only fueled the fire and some using the shield of "you are just a sexist, so you dont matter" as a deflection of the genuine critique of journalist ethics that gamergate originally stood for.Everything ofcourse just escalated with wingnuts from both the left and right jumping into the ring to see who screamed the loudest at each other. Turning the whole thing into a flame war of harassment and personal attacks from everyone. But that had nothing to do with Totalbiscuit or the original idea behind Gamergate. TB even goes into this in one of his videos (I don't recall of the top of my head), he never stood behind any of the doxxing or attacks
Also, TB did not "rise into fame" because of gamergate. he was already well known within the gaming community as he had worked with professional shoutcasting and Esports, and having even done gaming commentary on radio.
TB's highest all-time subscriber count was 2mill which he hit in 2015. His subscriber count was already at 1.5+ million subscribers before anything related with Gamergate went down. So that is just a flat out lie.Note also how the author writing this page, mentioned no actual substantial evidence to these claims, just deliberately misrepresenting the situation and making false conclusions.
-
NYNightTrain
commented
"That's a nice argument, Senator. Why don't you back it up with a source?"
-
Thelewsa
commented
(X) Doubt
-
cara_cstpa
commented
im questioning this now tho..
-
cara_cstpa
commented
i had no idea wtf
-
ZedXyr
commented
I learned about this from multiple channels I mod for. I had no idea! The Emote is even banned in some streams.
After how public GamerGate was, I am astonished this is still promoted by Twitch (Which started as a Game Streaming Platform)!
I remember GamerGate and have several Trans friends. I completely stand behind @FaeAlicia and feel Twitch should not wait for some "vote threshold" and take down TotalBiscuit's Emote immediately!
-
PoLLenCakes
commented
I didn't know either. I def don't think anyone should have to face a norm that is so harmful. People deserve to feel safe in their communities, we cannot give people tools to harass us.
-
FieryAshes
commented
Some of us literally have LUL banned in our chats because we don't want to see him? but that also means that we can't see our friend's emotes that have "LUL" instead of "LOL" as a spelling. Why do we have to put up with LUL when you at least changed out PogChamp when you needed to??
-
Ervo
commented
Thanks for telling this, I have no idea that streamer was related with GamerGate
-
BupForte
commented
Wow. Had no idea about this but that's absolute garbage that emote has been around for so long. Do better Twitch.
-
whois_ben
commented
This is *********. I figured it was based on a real twitch personality, but I've never even heard of this person. They changed Pog but not this?????