Settings and activity
6 results found
-
3,043 votes
JMcAfreak
supported this idea
·
-
236 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment -
2,211 votes
JMcAfreak
supported this idea
·
-
4,569 votes
JMcAfreak
supported this idea
·
-
39 votes
-
8,874 votes
Twitch
responded
Hi, thanks for flagging this and sharing your suggestion.
We share and understand your concerns about how the intentional, repeated misuse of tags can undermine the purpose of the tags product itself. Tags are an important discoverability feature for communities, and a powerful way for all Creators—but especially those that are underrepresented—to express their personal identity and creative vision for their content.
We also do not feel Twitch should be the judge of Creators’ personal or creative identity, so we typically only enforce against the misuse of tags when it is associated with other behavior that violates our Community Guidelines such as hateful conduct or harassment.
That said, as the VTuber community’s experience demonstrates, there are limitations to this approach and we are actively investigating additional steps we can take to protect and improve the integrity of the tags feature at scale, without infringing on good faith Creators’ personal choice…
An error occurred while saving the comment
JMcAfreak
commented
Tag misuse is a HUGE problem on Twitch, and it's never punished. I've seen people using tags that would NEVER apply to their stream, all the time. Like, it's one thing if, say, I forget to remove the speedrun tag from my stream when I'm not doing a speedrun, but it's another thing entirely for someone to just use a tag when they have no intention of doing that thing. Smaller streamers RELY on tags for discoverability. When big streamers such as Hasan, Amouranth, xQc, mizkif, and others deliberately put tags in their stream that don't actually match their channel (such as the vtuber tag), it hurts those smaller streamers.
If tags are to be a reliable way to sort content, then tag abuse needs to be punished swiftly and without regard to the size of the streamer.
TotalBiscuit was many things. A transphobe and a sexist he was not. He was painted as such despite his many words and actions to the contrary. He has defended the trans community many times over, including openly and at length expressing disgust at the "Are Traps Gay" question that was asked of Jesse Cox at a panel. Nothing in his history of statements, videos, interviews, or words, denotes him as a transphobe or a sexist.
TotalBiscuit DID NOT rise to fame for his support of GamerGate. His support of GamerGate was also STRICTLY on the grounds and belief that they were advocating for what they said they were advocating for: ethics in journalism. Game Journalistic ethics had been a pet cause of his for a long time before that. He, like many others in the movement (many of whom now denounce it if they are not right wing), had been fooled into an idea of the movement that just wasn't true. While there were sweeping elements of GamerGate that did harass women, he was a VOCAL opponent of said harassment. In an interview with David Pakman on the subject, he spoke at length about how he believed a group of trolls had hijacked and come to represent what people saw as GamerGate, and how he believed the fight had devolved into two armies fighting two wars on two different battlefields against two different enemies because of those trolls. He wanted no part in the harassment, and he made that ABUNDANTLY clear. He literally just wanted ethics in games journalism, a cause which he had been championing for quite some time before that. His support of GamerGate was ONLY on the premise that that's what it was actually about. If there ever was someone who truly believed that GG was only about ethics in games journalism, it was TotalBiscuit.
Many of the prominent figureheads of GG went right and became Trump supporters, such as Sargon and others (some, such as Milo Yiannopoulos, were already Trump supporters). TotalBiscuit was not one of them, and he drew intense mockery and harassment from the now-right wing GG supporters when he expressed his open and unwavering disgust that Trump had won the election (partially due to the harm it would do to women and trans folks). He and plenty of others who had supported GamerGate for its stated purpose (and not the actual purpose) either stayed left leaning or went further left when they realized the movement had been hijacked by the right. His staunch unwillingness to move Right-wing painted a target on his back by the very people who had been singing his praises during GamerGate. His support (and defense) of trans people, even when it was unpopular to do so, drew plenty of ire from people, fueled by right wing figureheads who HAD risen to fame as a result of GG.
Let's stop this slander, be it mistaken (which I believe it is) or outright malicious. GamerGate is a stain on his resume, sure. But he has done so many things to demonstrate that he did not support harassment of women or trans folks, and to the contrary, was willing to defend trans people from harm.