Ban the word "r*tard" and all variations from Twitch.
Ban the word "r*tard" and all variations from Twitch. This is hate speech. Recently, Twitch put a ban on words like "simp," "incel," and "virgin." Meanwhile, there are many partnered streamers, including Asmongold, one of the biggest streamers on Twitch, constantly using the R word and sees no problem with it, therefore influencing their audience of tens of thousands of Twitch users to do the same.
There are many, many, many articles on the internet explaining why and how the word is harmful, hate speech, and a slur. Most people don't even have to read them to know this. Recently a clip has surfaced of Asmongold saying he won't stop using the word unless he is banned. Ironically, he brings up a good point. Why is it that words like "incel" when used in a derogatory manner are bannable, but a word like "r*tard" which is MUCH more commonly thrown around as an insult, as well as being a more commonly known slur, is ok?
In Asmongold's words, on a Twitch live stream, "I don't think there is anything wrong with saying the word rtarded, and I think that the people that get mad about it are just ****** stupid. And I'm gonna keep saying it until they tell me I can't--If I say it they'll ban me right? Obviously, if I can't say it, I won't say it."
Your move, Twitch!
-
CanadianTick
commented
*******.
-
dustynutballin
commented
Oh boy, more pressures on free speech! Absolutely! Please nanny me more daddy Amazon!
What an L post. Just dont watch the people who say it and move on. I promise your entire life won't collapse if this word is allowed to be said. 99.9% of the time, this word isnt even used to target someone with a genuine intellectual disability. Get over yourself.
-
thy_demoness
commented
this is a hateful slur and should not be allowed on twitch
-
SmileySunshine_42
commented
Suspend streamers who say it once then ban them if the keep on saying it. Same goes for chatters. The r slur has no place on twitch. These comments are repulsive, the word is almost exclusively used as a slur now a days, so implementing a warning and bans for streamers and chatters that use this slur seems like a no brainer.
-
swagsphere6
commented
They need to ban slander too a twitch streamer was having a bad day and threatened me out of the blue and call me slander for no reason.
-
AlyMoss
commented
Just: No.
The Level 3 auto-mode is already generating false positives on an almost constant basis. Words that are blocked directly by the portal provider? Where will it end?Just:No. -
colonelyellomattercustard
commented
That's tarded. What is hateful about making a judgement of someone's lack of IQ points?
-
Sarge126
commented
only have a single issue with this idea.
The french word for 'late" is that exact word.
Example: "Sorry I am late" is "Désolé, je suis en r*tard"
Will this ban every french person off the platform?
-
gene_gay
commented
Its of concern because it's not just casual conversation, it's used as an attack against others. It's one thing to have an opinion or say something it's another to attack others
-
AcingEagle
commented
Before I am discussing it through, I want to ask, why is it your/our business how you fellow humans talk? Freedom of Speech is a very valuable basic human right, which shall not be infringed easily.
While I agree it might be resulting in an insult that is perceived as such, due to the way of usage, such applications fall under Twitch’s existing insult policy sections.
Most people won't feel offended by it, so it should not be seen as offending, excpet under special contexts which are already to be sanctioned on Twitch.
So all in all, censoring the whole community because you feel offended is a bit too much, I believe, but restricting insulting behavior, in such explicit contexts, is a good way of moderation.
-
legendaerii
commented
it is not a valid medical concept. it has been out of usage for a long time now. there are multiple better and less offensive ways to describe someone. context matters, and quite literally, most usage cases in twitch chats are going to be incorrect usages that are used to insult other people. sure, it might catch french people just using it to mean slow, but the vast majority of people it will catch are the problematic people. tired of people defending slurs. i can tell which people in these replies would get upset if this word was banned because they'd have to find a new insult. so. very. telling. you should get flagged if you use the word, and moderators should be able to decide your fate, t b h. it's obvious when someone isn't using it offensively, and obvious when someone is, all i'm sayin'. i'm not an autistic person who is offended by this word personally, being on the internet forever does that to you, but can still acknowledge it is hurtful to me and to others like me, and just because i'm not personally offended doesn't make it not a slur that should be looked into for banning.
-
Zeo_ICGF
commented
Absolutely not.
Using the word as an insult is wrong, but, it has a meaning.
socially, mentally or emotionally "r-tarted" is a valid medical concept. And like most mental health terms, it gets abused. banning words just causes other words to be used, usually incorrectly,
For instance , handicap is actually a better term then disabled. Handicap implies an internal or external issue preventing you from doing an action. Disabled implies the problem is all you, and that said action is a basic function..
Yet due to misguided feelers, from people like you, the more useful and accurate word has been replaced with a less accurate one.
Legitimate Words have meanings, and they can cause damage to legal processes and general understanding by being banned. Where as insults made for the sake of insults, like 2 of the other words you mentioned, are finne to nip in the bud.
but this particular word, unlike the others you mentioned, has more legitimate uses then not, and is a root word from Latin, as already discussed about French and Italian comon usage.
-
moonlitdia
commented
Don’t let them silence you
-
Love_N_Thunder
commented
I'd suggest getting over being offended by a word, and taking a closer look at how the word is used instead. Intent and context should be considered first over the words themselves.
For example in the UK a cigarette is called a F A G which is not offensive when used in that context. And there for someone in USA seeing that word automatically taking offense to that word, is then a personal problem, as words alone do not hold context until they are used within a context.
Another example of this is the word R (eh) P E which originally the meaning was to "to rob, strip, or plunder" of which can be used within the context to describe how a group of squirrels took (or stripped) all the nuts off a tree. Which is not exactly negative or bad. So to take offense to the words themselves is "R*tarded". Certain words are part of the nature of reality (to strip a tree of all it's nuts is to R (Eh) P E it).
Don't take offense to words take offense to how the words are used, as that is about intent.
If someone calls you an insulting name - the only reason it insults you is because you've trained yourself to take offense to it. In a better world we should avoid letting words hurt us - words are not harmful and do not contain intent (unless used with the context of intent).I really dislike being moderated to the point of everyone being forced to walk on eggshells about every little comment they make. I like having the freedom to speak openly about any words good or bad ones. And that is what many people need to learn to be able to let go of these judgements over the stigmatisms of words alone.
-
BooYeah84
commented
Boo ******* hoo
-
Labzaf
commented
In french, ****** means being late. So you can't ban the word "******".
-
stickwagongaming
commented
Twitch shouldn't ban any words. Its not hate speech unless someone uses it with the intent of it being hate speech. In that case the streamer should face the consequences not the word.
-
Something_Smith
commented
If you consider "the r-word" a slur, you're going to have to take a look at all the channels that allow the n-word. Cuz there are more than a few and there is no user verification to sort out the users who might be more allowed to use it than others. Nobody gets banned for that, do they?
Global bans for words are a hairy subject, because Twitch allows a lot of terrible things to be said on their platform, like the aforementioned racial slur, and others like it. If you want to start globally banning all slurs, you have a whole bunch of burning hoops to jump through to get it done.
If you want to use the argument about "taking the word back", I'm neurodivergent, and I'd like to take back the word rətard, please.
-
Metalus69
commented
You choose the communities you hang out in. Plenty of chats that don't let that word be said.
Best regards,
Metalus -
The_Notorious_M
commented
Banning words is the exact opposite of what should be happening