Replace AI-Generated Category Images with Human Made Work
For the creative/non-gaming categories, ESPECIALLY the art category, please replace the AI generated category images with credited, human-made images.
We've had the old category images for a while, they definitely could have used an overhaul. With the hiring and crediting of emote artists for new hype train emotes, some of us were cautiously optimistic that new category images would follow the same pattern. Twitch has a thriving creative community and it's no secret that many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. Many of us have had our work stolen with this technology.
Regardless of Twitch's view on the use of these technologies, the creative community as a whole has an overwhelmingly negative view on it—see the previous UserVoice to remove the Catinthechat emote with almost 14,000 upvotes here https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/928738-badges-emotes/suggestions/49188362-no-ai-for-global-emotes-change-catinthechat, as well as the hundreds of artists who came together to create new cats that could have easily been used for the emote. Moon worded it well in the UserVoice on the AI generated cat icons: "Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform."
Even the non-creative community seems upset at their images being AI image generations: https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/934332-customer-experience/suggestions/49173698-fix-the-ai-gerneated-category-image.
With this in mind, we ask that Twitch reconsider representing us, a community who OVERWHELMINGLY disapprove of the use of AI, with AI generated imagery that they could have instead asked one of the MANY creatives on Twitch to do. The 'Artists + Makers' creator club is full of multi-disciplined, highly creative, and very skilled folks who would be happy to take on the challenge of helping to remake not just the Art category, but all of the AI generated category images. Because, quite frankly—even with AI taken out of the picture—the new category images do not feel well representative of the groups they are supposed to be representing. For example, the Art category image captures only a sliver of the community it is supposed to represent, fine artists. It is a vibrant place filled with artists of every medium and genre! This image does not represent us well. Feel free to reach out to the members of your creator club for ideas, iteration, design, and work. We WANT Twitch to feel like home for us. We WANT to create and engage with the community. We do not want to be disregarded.
Please take advantage of the creativity and passion of your currently thriving creative community, instead of taking actions that at best read out of touch and careless towards them. If creatives feel like the platform is actively hostile towards them, that thriving community will start to dwindle. Don't do that to us.
-
macoud12
commented
The words ring true. WHY. Why did you resort to using AI-generated slop for category images when there's literal hundreds if not thousands of artists on this platform who would have jumped at the chance to make something custom for that.
-
Spec1799
commented
1. This is disrespectful to the artists that work *in* that category.
2. The ability to hire an artist to make banner art would be less troublesome than using any sort of AI.
3. This would turn people away from such categorys because of the immensive dislike of AI usage.TLDR Don't Use AI Like This.
-
iampuddleglum
commented
Using AI art for this, especially for the Art category, is a slap in the face to the many creators who are trying to earn their livelihood by making their own art.
-
tv_ennui
commented
Gross that Twitch is doing/considering this.
-
kagedokai
commented
This is an absolute disgrace to all the people who make your platform what it is. Use art made by real people who are compensated for it!
-
nurvuss
commented
It's a slap in the face to all of twitch's wonderful creators to use AI for its categories. Amazon can afford to commission a few images.
-
DesertLeviathan
commented
Companies that use AI "Art" do not receive my business. Sounds like it's time to cancel all my Twitch subscriptions, convert my sub cost over to monthly Ko-Fi donations, and watch their streams on Youtube instead.
-
JSGonTwitch
commented
Literally just commission an artist to make a new category banner with your vision as Twitch; WHY would you want to signal to your user-base that you are going the cheap route when it comes to your User Experience Design!?!?!
-
ocarinia
commented
It is disrespectful to use GenAI for the Category Images, especially for the Art category. Why can we not celebrate the artists on Twitch by hiring them?
Or why not at least hire other human artists to show that you stand by the mass amounts of creators on your platform, who are constantly harmed by the effects of Generative AI online and off?
-
DigitalVagrant
commented
You literally ARE a website whose whole BUISNESS is hosting content made by creators. That is your entire premise. Any one of us, and there are MILLIONS of us, would have jumped at the chance to make thumbnails for you. Heck, you could have turned it into a showcase; rotating thumbnails, weekly or monthly, with a little note saying who drew this one. Thereby showcasing some of the talent on your site, potentially turning them into higher earners, and making things more fun and interesting.
The fact that you chose to use AI instead is a decision that is both soulless and betrays a complete and utter lack of imagination, as well as being completely divorced from what is needed to make this website continue to grow and succeed.
Be better than this.
-
hayhaiya
commented
AI generated images look awful and actively turn me away from using a site or ever giving it any money. Just pay people to make things, it isn't that hard and it also doesn't alienate a massive percentage of people.
-
TeenyNyx
commented
Way to spit in the face of every artist and creator who uses you to reach their audiences. Shame on you for this insult to the arts, no one wanted or asked for this. Do better for the streamers that continue to line your pockets with their hard earned money. Use some of the sub money you're robbing from the little guys to hire real artists.
-
stereobass
commented
I don't want to use the Art category tag because using genAI art as the image category implies my endorsement to genAI being used to replace hiring for artists to create these pieces. This is not okay to shadow change the category art like this. "Investing" into genAI is not going to pan out - it's a waste of money and resources and algorithmically, a terrible efficiency. Do better.
-
Chilari
commented
AI generated images are not art. Art requires soul, intention, deliberation. Representing creative categories with images created by a machine that has no understanding of creativity is a mockery and an insult to the hard work artists undertake to learn to make art, and those whose work was stolen to train the algorithm. If Bezos can't afford to pay real artists, maybe he should sell the platform to someone who can and will.
-
spookybiscuits
commented
Using AI to create these images instead of working with the vast wealth of creative talent on Twitch is a huge missed opportunity to showcase Twitch's creative power. We can do better!
-
Aringrey
commented
The use of AI imagery on twitch is a worrying trend I would like to see end. Pay human designers who spent a lifetime perfecting their craft and know what they are doing. I promise it will have more heart than this carp.
-
antigravbear
commented
So many people on Twitch give their all to create art through entertaining others, everyone gets a chance to get to make something here, no matter how big or small they are.
That should include the category images, there are so many human artists out there that could make the art themselves, it could even be a new opportunity for themselves to get more work, but using AI/LLM images will just take those opportunities away from them.
-
Lurdiak
commented
This is insulting to every creator on twitch. Get that garbage off your website, I don't care if you replace it with nothing.
-
Jerimiah40
commented
GenAI is a disgusting form of plagiarism, but using it to generate assets for a platform where artists are supposed to be able to thrive and make a living is a whole other level of middle finger. There are countless artists who would happily accept a commission to design category images for Twitch, to replace them with AI shows laziness and a complete lack of respect for the creatives who keep the platform alive.
-
JackieTheRaccoon
commented
Twitch this is an AWFUL choice. GenAI is horrid and harmful to your creators AND our environment. Hire actual artists and stop using slop.