Replace AI-Generated Category Images with Human Made Work
For the creative/non-gaming categories, ESPECIALLY the art category, please replace the AI generated category images with credited, human-made images.
We've had the old category images for a while, they definitely could have used an overhaul. With the hiring and crediting of emote artists for new hype train emotes, some of us were cautiously optimistic that new category images would follow the same pattern. Twitch has a thriving creative community and it's no secret that many of us take issue with the way that generative AI, in its current state has ethical issues regarding the lack of transparency, lack of compensation, lack of credit, and and lack of consent—not to mention devastating environmental impacts. Many of us have had our work stolen with this technology.
Regardless of Twitch's view on the use of these technologies, the creative community as a whole has an overwhelmingly negative view on it—see the previous UserVoice to remove the Catinthechat emote with almost 14,000 upvotes here https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/928738-badges-emotes/suggestions/49188362-no-ai-for-global-emotes-change-catinthechat, as well as the hundreds of artists who came together to create new cats that could have easily been used for the emote. Moon worded it well in the UserVoice on the AI generated cat icons: "Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform."
Even the non-creative community seems upset at their images being AI image generations: https://twitch.uservoice.com/forums/934332-customer-experience/suggestions/49173698-fix-the-ai-gerneated-category-image.
With this in mind, we ask that Twitch reconsider representing us, a community who OVERWHELMINGLY disapprove of the use of AI, with AI generated imagery that they could have instead asked one of the MANY creatives on Twitch to do. The 'Artists + Makers' creator club is full of multi-disciplined, highly creative, and very skilled folks who would be happy to take on the challenge of helping to remake not just the Art category, but all of the AI generated category images. Because, quite frankly—even with AI taken out of the picture—the new category images do not feel well representative of the groups they are supposed to be representing. For example, the Art category image captures only a sliver of the community it is supposed to represent, fine artists. It is a vibrant place filled with artists of every medium and genre! This image does not represent us well. Feel free to reach out to the members of your creator club for ideas, iteration, design, and work. We WANT Twitch to feel like home for us. We WANT to create and engage with the community. We do not want to be disregarded.
Please take advantage of the creativity and passion of your currently thriving creative community, instead of taking actions that at best read out of touch and careless towards them. If creatives feel like the platform is actively hostile towards them, that thriving community will start to dwindle. Don't do that to us.
-
DarkAura64
commented
Twitch is a platform for real people to express themselves and their interests - kindly allow the categories to reflect that with real work by real people.
-
OmiNomomi
commented
There's literally an entire category dedicated to art. Why should I care about a logo no one cared to actually create?
-
KingTheKeeper
commented
Hire ACTUAL artists rather than taking the lazy way out like this. This just shows you don't care about the creatives that are on your platform, you only care about cutting corners and making more money to line your pockets. Pay actual artists, hire actual artists, and stop making Twitch worse and worse every single year because you want to save a quick buck.
-
Aspinator8675
commented
The original icons are what make twitch real, don’t change them for AI
-
1upGaming1up
commented
AI will hurt Twitch if this keeps up
-
NeonSaline
commented
Using AI is an actual insult to all the artists that both work for and use your platform.
-
Lilin_VDaemon
commented
Using AI-generated images for any category is ridiculous, but especially for the Art category. I'd rather see the "graphic design is my passion" meme as category art than anything AI.
-
CappuDiceGod
commented
There's literally an entire category dedicated to Art. This is practically a SEARS catalogue for Twitch to choose from in terms of hiring artists to add flair to the site. Why on earth would they spit in the face of them like this?
-
Drigadoom
commented
Hire real artist especially with how many artist are on the twitch platform as a whole messed up part is many of them would do it for free or even a heavily discounted price so they could be on the big screen of twitch please stop the use of Ai art!
-
magicthunderlemon
commented
The new category image could of been made during an online art lesson in 3 minutes, generative AI is lazy and doesn't exactly send a welcoming message towards the artist community (many of whom you could of commissioned directly to make something by the way) when the new image instead screams "Graphic design is my passion". The lack of effort is vastly noticeable with the new image and like any use of generative AI, is rightly receiving outcry.
You can do better than this Twitch, cmon
-
AshsToAshs
commented
Twitch, so much of your community is artists. Not just people that stream, but so many additional artists support twitch by making emotes, vtubers, and other streaming assets.
The use of generative AI for these new category banners is both lazy and disrespectful.
This can end up being a super easy win for you: commission some of the artists from the twitch community to design these banners. And put out a statement addressing concerns of how twitch plans to use (and hopefully not use going forward) generative AI for art. -
astralouve
commented
Twitch is a platform with hundreds if not thousands of artists who utilize its services to stream their processes to others. Choosing to actively be apart of and use AI is such a disgrace to those users and shows you truly do not care about them.
It is a very insulting choice as artists make up a part of the back bone of Twitch and many of them will choose to take their practices elsewhere as a result.
You are actively ruining your own platform and business by choosing to partake in something that not only actively impacts the environment around us but also a massive portion of your user base.
You have hundreds of artists who would've been happy to contribute to the platform and you chose to actively spit in our faces. It is not a good look. I can only hope our voices are heard and actions are taken to remedy this.
Do better. -
Goofus_T_Faust
commented
What is the point of choosing AI over real people in this case? Would it not have been infinitely cooler to use art from the actual community? You could have even had a contest or something like that, made it a "hype moment" or something like that. Using AI-generated assets here makes it seem like there was little to no thought put into the decision at all.
-
Schrei205
commented
Come on Twitch. There's literally so many artists who would be incredibly honored to do this, probably even just for credit. Stop using generative AI. It's so ugly.
-
fragrantboglaurel
commented
Hi all! I notice a lot of folks are speaking to the ethical concerns and overall impacts of generative AI on artists and anything I would have to say has already been said. I'm going to focus on some less discussed criticisms I have of the change. Just wanted to clarify that because these are secondary to the bigger issues already being discussed by the Original Poster and other commenters and I don't want to detract from that. Human rights and ethics should always come first, to deny that is negligence.
Why was this necessary? As pointed out by others, the category images have become less descriptive/informative than before. Overall I think we were quite pleased with the category images and I think overhauling them majorly makes things less recognizable. I also know that most AI models aren't free, so there was some level of investment in this unnecessary change. As others have said, this could be allocated to artists be it through individual pieces or hiring a dedicated artist for your team. (And even if it didn't cost anything - why fix something that isn't broken with a solution that will isolate the people using your platform?)
Putting on the business talking hat now for addressing the corporate side of things. It's important to remember that this is a creator driven platform, and making choices that negatively impact artists will have negative impacts for all independent creators. This is also a dangerous precedent to set in community spaces, and Twitch is an industry leader. Supporting generative AI will undermine your company's overall goals and integrating generative AI and generative AI content will lead to cognitive dissonance, unclear corporate goals and potentially even greater social/industry changes that would not reflect kindly on Twitch.
As more and more content is generated by generative AI, the space becomes even more competitive for content creators than it already is. While at first glance this may seem sustainable (i.e. more users being drawn in), the content on your platform is going to suffer greatly due to the current capabilities of AI. AI technology has been widely overpromised, overcharged and underdelivered, if you have further plans (which I would suspect, perhaps this was a "test run" of sorts) beyond just changing these icons, they may not even be plausible at this point or anytime in the near future.
Not only that, generative AI is predominantly trained by "scraping" information off of the internet at large - the presence of any generative AI content will inherently make artists feel less comfortable sharing anything on platforms where they fear their art may be used in ways without their consent. Outside of the Art space, this is still an issue - creators may not consent to having things like webcams, voices, video clips, etc. scraped by AI and may not understand the extent to which Twitch is working with generative AI. Alienating the primary users of your platform is a recipe for disaster.
Many countries are also implementing AI regulation and this could have international impacts with regard to liability. Knowing that Twitch is a multinational company, this could have major legal impacts - especially for something with much international legislation still being codified. Whatever money will be saved with generative AI is negligible should legal action come into play. There is a lot of risk that comes with rolling out AI on a platform alone, let alone one that is so populated by people who are negatively impacted by the presence alone of generative AI.
-
Viperseviper23
commented
This is a huge slap in the face for the streamers who are in the artist community. I also was thinking about starting streaming but as my content would be model making this is just the nail in the coffin to NOT stream at all.
-
SharkyAenne
commented
Gen AI is wrong on all levels. It steals art from real artists - which a lot of artists also stream their art on twitch! - it's killing our environment, and it just looks bad. I'm sad that Twitch thinks that a website, that's full are content creators, would choose to use something that morally goes against creation of content! (Gen AI produced stuff is never and will never be content )
-
TieDyeBlahaj
commented
To phrase this in words a business-minded individual might be able to understand: ignoring the fact that generative AI is morally reprehensible, inherently destructive and exists solely off of plagiarism, even after ignoring that, using generative AI or even the mentioning of using it has utterly destroyed other platform's profits and commercial reputation. As a business decision *in and of itself*, it is a terrible idea. Utterly embarrassing. I offer a denouncement to whomever thought it was a good idea.
-
Xepter_
commented
The use of IA in this way only harms the livelihood of thousand of human artists. This do not have other purpose than to serve to corporations or industries to create more products at lower prices, ignoring everything else in the process. This IA tool for images do not serve a purpose to help artists, just to undermine them.
-
Artifedex
commented
Choosing to ignore all the very skilled artists in favor of a computer generated mess? On top of that, the generation of AI images puts our environment at risk! I do not approve of this change, and feel insulted as both an artist, and as a viewer, that Twitch would make these images instead of using the opportunity to commission new ones from a real artist.