No AI for global emotes, change CatintheChat
It is obvious from the disconnected whisker, uncanny expression, and strange anatomy that the holiday emote :CatintheChat: is AI generated. I speak on behalf of the artists on your platform who have had our livelihoods threatened by generative AI, as well as those with numerous ethical concerns- from datasets consisting of stolen and copyrighted work to environmental issues for immense amounts of energy spent on image generation.
From a marketing and business perspective, the money you save releasing AI emotes isn't worth the negative PR, especially compared to the positive PR and community building that would result from featuring one of the creatives on your platform instead.
Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform. The response on social media is very clear: rather than a fun feature to celebrate holidays, all the conversation is about how people don't want AI emotes anywhere near their channel or how they wish you would have worked with one of the many artists on your platform to create it.
This feels like a complete slap in the face after you just released the Artist Creator Club, which seemed like a real effort to support creatives on Twitch. Those efforts ring hollow compared to your actions by releasing this emote.
Make it right. Remove the emote and replace it with something either drawn by a real artist or edited from a real photo. Promise to prevent all future use of generative AI in global emotes so that those of us who oppose it never have to see this harmful practice being used in our chats.
-
Cdbarnezy
commented
Twitch have created the Artist & Makers Creator Club, as a Member of this it kinda feels like a slap in a face... come on we just had a great team of artist spend weeks on holiday themed emotes you could of used ANY ONE OF THEM... here they are: https://x.com/plushunagi/status/1863281498100580686?s=46
-
BagelGremlin
commented
Why should we give you money, content, and patronage when you can't be bothered to hire and pay for actual artists?
-
DulceDoes
commented
No AI please
-
pixiemuledonkey
commented
WE. DO. NOT. WANT. AI. I don't know how many other ways to tell you this, but nobody on Earth wants generative AI slop except for:
* Tech industry con-artists whose continued existence depends on tricking investors into believing their theft-based curiosity will ever develop into something that generates a profit instead of devouring billions of dollars for no good reason whatsoever, and
* Overpaid executives who despise the working class so bitterly that they will seize upon any opportunity to exploit people and steal things that don't belong to them while claiming to be more important to the profit of Twitch than the people who ACTUALLY CREATE THE THINGS PEOPLE WATCH TWITCH FOR IN THE FIRST PLACE.
There is no shortage of working artists streaming on this very website, you see? Like, there's a WHOLE LOT of them. Almost any of them could be commissioned to create emotes for Twitch's usage.
And you know the best part? None of them, by creating artwork, are actively destroying the environment of the planet we all live on - including Twitch executives, believe it or not - unlike the heat-generating, electricity-hogging, water-evaporating generative AI slop that everyone hates. AND, by commissioning - AND PAYING - artists for their work, you can also prove to Anubis that your heart isn't leaden and blackened by contempt for working class people just trying to survive in the capitalist hellscape your boss has a hand in making.
So, perhaps, as a little Christmas miracle this year, perhaps Twitch could STOP trying to slip generative AI feces into our mouths every few months in the hopes that we won't notice their pattern of utter contempt for the creators they regularly exploit in order to line Jeff Bezos' sweat-stained hatband with blood diamonds and Dalmatian puppy fur.
STOP MAKING THE WORLD A WORSE PLACE, TWITCH, FOR GOD'S SAKE.
-
lunar_dvst
commented
AI is so bad, you could’ve gotten an actual artist. If you wanted it realistic/photograph quality, grab a kitten, a lickable treat, a good camera and a tiny Santa hat. There ARE other ways than AI.
-
JoCat
commented
one of the largest businesses in streaming is making art assets for overlays, vtuber models, icons, panels, notifications, and emotes. by making emotes with AI, twitch makes clear that they do not respect the time, effort, or skill of real artists who's work gets stolen and fed into ai data banks
-
MaelstromWolf
commented
Couldn't find a real cat to put a Santa hat on? Get this AI garbage out of here.
-
Stren_VT
commented
This could have:
Been made by an artist, who would have put work into it, adding both human value to it and bringing In the community to contribute to part of twitch
OR
just... an actual photo. like...
its probably out there
It probably wouldn't be hard to set up if not.
but instead you chose to, in one action, disrespect every single self respecting artist on your platform by using this AI slot. come on twitch, do better.
and since its cooperate brain we probably have to get through to: It would probably be CHEAPER THAN PAYING FOR AI SERVICES (and better for the environment to)
Seriously though, for a SINGULAR emote most artists dont even charge that much, and you get what ya want immediately, you dont have to generate dozens if not hundreds of ai vomit images to get one "decent" one (it still looks like hecc)
OH WAIT
THERES ALSO PHOTOSHOP YOU CAN USE
Ya'll really dont care much for the community huh? -
RevSpicy
commented
If you're looking for an extremely efficient and effective way to destroy your users' trust, Twitch has very clearly found it!
Not only does this spit in the face of every artist in the community, but to many of those fighting to bring a positive ecological/environmental change through the site's usage of charities too.
There is such an amazing thoughtlessness to the release of this emote and the fact that it made it all the way to release in this way shows Twitch's priorities and how it feels about its users very clearly.
-
moderufox
commented
Ai art is the most garbage thing to ever exist. THOUSANDS OF ARTIST AND YOU CHOOSE LAZINESS AND SLOP OVER AN ARTIST TO DRAW ONE EMOTE. This is unacceptable in every way.
-
DragonShurrin
commented
I agree with OP. This is very disappointing and makes it seem like Twitch does not care about the artists on their platform. Someone goofed with this idea. Now it is time to fix it and do better.
-
smurfberribbq
commented
Come on, Twitch. This seems like it was an exercise in pure laziness. Paying someone for an emote isn't going to break the bank of a company the size of Twitch.
-
rae_sora
commented
AI is for losers.
-
Inkling0
commented
No AI! Artists are already struggling, we don't need to make it worse. Either use random funny moments like ResidentSleeper or commission someone to make new emojis, NOT AI!!!
-
hatsunemikulover666
commented
COME ON, ARE YOU SERIOUS NOW??? You have thousands of amazing skilled artists who would be more than willing to draw emotes for you. So many artists would love to draw for you, so why use AI slop!? AI slop is bad morally, environmentally, and visually.
“Oh yes, I would love for AI to drink a pint of water and burn half of a tree so that I can generate amalgamated slop instead of the prettier art tehehehe!” NO. STOP. HIRE ARTISTS OR GET BENT.
-
Dreddknott1998
commented
AI will never attain a fraction of the pure heart and spirit that goes into art.
-
ArunaLavender
commented
Ai is trash
-
tallershadow
commented
AI is pretty wack just have a artist do it
-
RejTeeVee
commented
Unfortunate that they would even consider this
-
cawkins_
commented
There are so many artists that they could have chosen on their own platform to do these emojis but they rather used ai for it. That is really disappointing.