No AI for global emotes, change CatintheChat
It is obvious from the disconnected whisker, uncanny expression, and strange anatomy that the holiday emote :CatintheChat: is AI generated. I speak on behalf of the artists on your platform who have had our livelihoods threatened by generative AI, as well as those with numerous ethical concerns- from datasets consisting of stolen and copyrighted work to environmental issues for immense amounts of energy spent on image generation.
From a marketing and business perspective, the money you save releasing AI emotes isn't worth the negative PR, especially compared to the positive PR and community building that would result from featuring one of the creatives on your platform instead.
Optics are important and this sends a clear message that you do not care about the artists working on your platform. The response on social media is very clear: rather than a fun feature to celebrate holidays, all the conversation is about how people don't want AI emotes anywhere near their channel or how they wish you would have worked with one of the many artists on your platform to create it.
This feels like a complete slap in the face after you just released the Artist Creator Club, which seemed like a real effort to support creatives on Twitch. Those efforts ring hollow compared to your actions by releasing this emote.
Make it right. Remove the emote and replace it with something either drawn by a real artist or edited from a real photo. Promise to prevent all future use of generative AI in global emotes so that those of us who oppose it never have to see this harmful practice being used in our chats.
-
itanshi
commented
it is a very ugly emote when you enlarge it. this is not the quality i expect from twitch and you are offending the entire artist category, see if i'm wrong
-
BunnyN00dles
commented
i agree with everyone with these needing to be removed , because if it was a streamer itd be removed ... its only fair if twitch has these removed too !
-
SkinWalkers
commented
DON'T USE AI
-
TahGrizly
commented
Friggin greedy *** corporations, sticking it to the very people that bring in their money... There's hundreds of thousands of perfectly capable artists that are using their platform every single day that sell their services for pennies on the dollar and they choose to do what? Bro, if it wasn't for people that I hold dear and me trying to support their efforts, I'd have sworn off the platform ages ago. This one is just another nail in the coffin towards taht end. And imagine how hard that coffin will drop when every square inch of it is covered in nails.
-
Nayeba
commented
Another company being lazy and using AI garbage.
-
lavsunrise
commented
Imagine having an entire platform full of creatives, and then slapping all of us in the face with AI generated content. Real classy move Twitch, GG go next
-
CozyGothGF
commented
GG on breaking your own TOS by using AI for emotes, Twitch. Also you have SO many amazing artists on your platform, literally spoiled for choice, and you still chose AI?? Good lawd get it together or sell the company to someone who can actually run it well.
-
オクトゲイシャ
commented
Upon review of ai art twitch has broken their own community guideline of Intellectual Property Rights (seen here https://safety.twitch.tv/s/article/Community-Guidelines?language=ja)
Generative AI is stolen material
i agree with everyone with these needing to be removed , because if it was a streamer itd be removed ... its only fair if twitch has these removed too !
-
Auburn_Arcana
commented
Twitch has done a lot for me personally and professionally. As an artist, I feel like I have a valuable platform to not only show my work, but find and sometimes even work with other amazing people.
A part of these valuable experiences has happened because of artists' creativity and originality. From my experience, artists are not only capable of being professional subject matter experts in making meaningful, tasteful, quality works, but can also know a variety of other subjects (psychology in my case!).
It's because of that and all of the ethical and practical reasons cited by others that I feel crushed about the prospect of Twitch endorsing what amounts to mass copyright infringement. Simply because a system has stolen from too many creators to count doesn't mean that it has no longer stolen from anybody.
Overall, artists' work is valuable, and artists themselves are worth protecting. I would like to join the call on Twitch to recall & replace this and any other emotes that were made with unsourced/stolen material.
-
Rabid_Hound
commented
You have so many artists or photo editors that would JUMP at the opportunity to do a global emote for Twitch yet you chose to go the lazy sloppy way of using AI.
You could have had a contest to do a global emote, paid an artist or had a Twitch staff member edit a photo of their cat with a Santa hat. -
paprika_the_pierrot
commented
You have so many artists on your platform and you use AI? I'd say I'm surprised but I'm not. But I did hope for better from twitch.
-
Cassodile
commented
twitch?? ai is not cool why would u do that ?????
-
gradgartwitch
commented
All those streamers out there paying artists for their finely crafted emotes and the company worth BILLIONS is pumping out AI slop.
It's like getting an empty box for Christmas. Wow Twitch. Way to let everyone know what little you think of them.
-
ProjectJeff85
commented
AI should be used for the AI of your virtual teammates in single-player games.
NOT for artwork, videos and emotes stolen from artists. Is it too much to ask?
-
ArakATK
commented
I am 100% banning this phrase from my chat. This emote will not be used on my channel. I do not support the use of generative AI never going to. If you've paid for every step of the way sure, fine, but this was a single image. You're a platform for creatives and you just slapped every single one of us in the face. Most of us could have produced higher quality images, most of those would probably have done it for free. There is zero excuse for you to lead a site of creatives and then "celebrate" in such a TONE DEAF way by using something that directly threatens many of their livelihoods. You have made a lot of awful decisions lately, whoever it was you just hired into middle management needs to spend some time at a creator summit, so they can have some idea what we as the content creators of this platform want.
-
EmotionalDerps
commented
Commenting on the "artists are just jealous" post - you see, most people while upset about ai in general are actually mostly upset that people generate it to trace for commissions or generate it for some kind of profit in general. Stealing people's money with lies on top of the art is what people have a problem with.
And if you really truly thought this wasn't wrong, then why do all these accounts that get called out for ai feel they need to delete their account and "rebrand" to keep selling? If there's "nothing wrong", why are ya'll running like cowards? Someone who isn't guilty doesn't do that. Just sayin.
-
MidnightSighs
commented
Why is everyone assuming it's AI? Because of a whisker? As an artist, I've left stray lines like that all the time...The connection to the nose/mouth is more strange, but....that could still be bad photoshop, too.
Because the texture and hair in the hat? The texture in the mouth? The fur all going the right way? The lack of strange pixelization when you zoom in? I don't know for sure that it IS AI and isn't just a photoshopped image. Or a combination of the two? We don't know, is the problem.
And for everyone who will say "they can just show a WIP" - not all artists take WIP shots or save them. That doesn't appease some communities. After all this, if there is an artist, they may be too embarrassed to take credit, or they were fire for bad PR if they existed in the first place.
I think we're getting so gung ho on AI witchhunts that we're quicker to assuming something is than isn't. While I agree with the message and the thought that yes, Twitch could use a staff cat (and market it as such) or use community artists - but I think we need to be careful in accusations too.
-
EleshPlays
commented
So many artists on the platform, and you can't find one you want to help out by commissioning an emote from? You're not even trying...
-
Lemon_Drizzle
commented
I’ll be auto timing out anyone that use this emote. A platform filled with artists and they went with a AI is a disgusting act
-
ThunderBiome
commented
What's worse, is that cat abomination is doing the ahaego face.
You could have done a photograph of one of the cats of twitch staff to make it more wholesome and relatable.