Allow PG "Dumpy" style emotes on Twitch.
A Dumpy emote is an emote with a shaking butt in a circle and does not contain nudity or sexually explicit content of any kind. There are over 900 of them on Twitch as of this writing.
Dumpy emotes are incredibly popular among a wide number of communities on Twitch. However, they have been removed by Twitch Moderation at seemingly random for violating the community guidelines.
Context Here: https://twitter.com/PirateSoftware/status/1686114277491650560
As these emotes are based on a draw-over of the PG movie Open Season from 2006 it seems absurd to ban them from the platform.
Context Here: https://twitter.com/PirateSoftware/status/1686127545429942278
Non-sexualized animal butt emotes are allowed per our emote guidelines. Closing this submission - thank you.
-
agathas777
commented
These dumpy emotes are just harmless ferret butts shaking in circles. It does not show any human dumpy and it is just a cute ferret's behind. Thank you and we hope you make an exception for this dumpy!
-
SaltySilvaeth
commented
I agree with the sentiment from PirateSoftware. I can understand twitch not wanting explicit content on their platform. Provided it is not containing nudity or sexually explicit content what is the harm in allowing people to have these silly emotes. They provide fun and joy.
-
Resrie_san
commented
We as the followers of piratesoftware really love and thrive with this emote. Please allow us to use the emote again. It is a fun and goofy emote that is not inappropriate or harmful in anyway.
-
Maidenframe
commented
Stop trolling Twitch. Give us Dumpy and UNDERBOOB.
-
DreamersThistle
commented
The "dumpy" emote is purely a comedic and silly emote that helps bring the community together through a humorous collective cheer such as a pog or cheer. This emote is seen as both a tool for humour and jesting at the streamer and is not a symbol of anything sexually explicit. Thank you for your consideration, and I'm sure we could settle on adjustments if the team has any recommendations
-
AmatuerShrink
commented
The use of this emote (yarrDumpy) is meant to be humorous and light hearted, its use does not connotate anything explicit or sexual, its original source is also PG.
While I agree that sexual content should be kept off Twitch animated cartoon animals shaking a blank butt does not fall under that umbrella in my opinion.
-
CMDR_DerFlob
commented
The Dumpy emote may violate the exact letter of TOS, but definitely not the spirit nor the intentions that come across. Just like Gasm-style emotes, which are explicitly allowed even though they are definitely somewhat sexual in nature, Dumpy-style emotes deserve their own specific exemption.
-
RussEby
commented
This type of emotes shouldn't violate any guideline. It's fun and funny. I see nothing wrong with it.
-
fudego
commented
I've seen the emote and it doesn't look like it violates any community guidelines.
-
Norm1226
commented
Agreed! Dumpy styled emotes are widely loved by the Twitch community and for the most part, these emotes are created in a light hearted manner for the purpose of positive engagement in chat among viewers. The claim that this emote is at all "sexual" is false as it came from a 21st century children's movie that had a PG rating.
-
LukeSooks
commented
While I understand the need to ban sexual content however I believe that dumpy style emotes are not sexually explicit itself. It’s based off of an animated PG movie and if it’s fine for cable TV then it should be more than appropriate for Twitch. Thank you for taking the time to read this comment and hope we can come to a mutual understanding on this issue
-
centaurianmudpig
commented
The dump emote is a fun emote to use in Twitch chat. Those creating dumpies in good faith have done so without any sexual meaning since it's been traced from a PG-rated film. Selectively removal of dumpies is very sad to see. TOS rules should make an exception for animals and or animated characters unless they are made to be sexually explicit and dealt with in each instance. You should also allow the content creator to appeal their emotes flagged as breaching TOS.
-
thane_the_tree
commented
I understand Twitch is going through some changes in their policies regarding sexual content and their identity as a platform. However, emotes in this style do not fit the TOS rules, in my opinion, especially for animals or animated characters.
with regards a real human being . . . . . i hope
-
velsigh
commented
I agree that this emotion is not against TOS and does not carry any sexual context. This is just a funny and cute animal animation. The author even indicated that she looks like a cartoon, with a rating of PG-13.
-
EggFriedCheese
commented
There are significantly more channels across Twitch that have way more "offensive" emotes, including those that are showing full "butt-cheeks", or even partial nudity, which still remain on twitch.
Dumpy emotes do not contain any nudity in any fashion, and for specifics, the emote that has been removed recently, has no nudity, and should not go against Twitch ToS.
I can understand that some people will have "pushed the line" with the changes in the content guidelines, but I feel that much more clarification will be needed for "What is allowed", and "Where twitch will draw the line", because currently, I feel that the limitations are extremely strict, on emotes that are not sexually explicit, especially around animated emotes (and not human imitation content).
-
ulysses3
commented
I agree with this, I believe the ToS needs to be adjusted/updated to reflect this style of content.
-
TalviTheFox
commented
Hold up, Twitch?! Removing Dumpy emotes feels unfair. They're just happy butts, like PogChamp's head or Kappa's tongue, right? No nudity, just meme culture inspired by a PG movie. Plus, these emotes bring communities together! So many people love them.
Instead of a ban, maybe age-gate them or have a stricter approval process? Let's keep Twitch fun and inclusive, not confusing!
#BringBackDumpyEmotes #TwitchLogic
-
efjr1
commented
I do not see anything explicit with this emote. If it was appropriate enough for a kids movie then there is nothing wrong with it. It isn't inappropriate, it's fun for the community.
-
Ni3po42
commented
This is a harmless emote. It's fun and I would even show this to my 3 year old, she'd think it's funny.
-
Psychicash
commented
nothing wrong with the emote. Come on twitch. Of all the emotes you could ban you picked one that is based on a pg movie? Seriously?