Allow PG "Dumpy" style emotes on Twitch.
A Dumpy emote is an emote with a shaking butt in a circle and does not contain nudity or sexually explicit content of any kind. There are over 900 of them on Twitch as of this writing.
Dumpy emotes are incredibly popular among a wide number of communities on Twitch. However, they have been removed by Twitch Moderation at seemingly random for violating the community guidelines.
Context Here: https://twitter.com/PirateSoftware/status/1686114277491650560
As these emotes are based on a draw-over of the PG movie Open Season from 2006 it seems absurd to ban them from the platform.
Context Here: https://twitter.com/PirateSoftware/status/1686127545429942278
Non-sexualized animal butt emotes are allowed per our emote guidelines. Closing this submission - thank you.
-
Easley18
commented
The fact that twitch allows for people to physically twerk now should mean that the dumpy style emotes are 100% allowed. These emotes have NOTHING to do with sexuality and are there for fun. Definitely shouldn't be against TOS
-
AserAsh
commented
Agreed, there is no reason to remove dumpy emotes. I want mine back!
-
NowanFox
commented
Agreed! I had an emote in this style and it was the most popular one on my channel until it was removed for being "sexual in nature." There's nothing sexual about a cartoon animal with no buttocks or genitalia spinning its tail. It's not nudity, it's not sexual.
-
BobaBombaZz
commented
Dumpy shouldn't be ToS NODDERS
-
nixalott
commented
Cmon twitch! This is not nudity nor sexual content! This is just a cartoonish ferret dancing with butt covered in fur!
-
EBthePurple
commented
It is a dancing ferret, there isn't anything sexual about it. If there is, then Open Season, should not have been rated PG.
-
NoahTheOtter
commented
Free the Dumpy!!! Allow these emotes for everyone
-
TheChefMeow
commented
A cartoon animal shaking its butt in a circle does not contain anything sexually explicit or even suggestive. It doesn't sexualize an animal, it doesn't sexualize anything at all. Communities heavily enjoy these emotes, as they embody those communities' love of fun. By removing these emotes for violating the sexual content policy, Twitch is not only looking down on its community and creators by assuming that they are sexualizing animals, but also itself sexualizing those animals by proclaiming they are violating sexual content policy.
Dumpy's are animated drawings of cartoon animals. They do not display or convey or allude to real, human buttocks. They're animals, they aren't sexual.
-
DnnrPants
commented
I had my dumper emotes removed of my little purple imp character removed. I ALSO had an emote of my corgi shaking tail removed. Both of them were harmless and I hope to see some sort of change to allow them back on the platform.
-
Adora_Bunny
commented
These emotes are harmless fun and very much referenced in even children’s cartoons and movies. Please allow communities to have them once more.
-
muffincupkelly
commented
just wholesome memes
-
Unoraptormon
commented
It's something cute to put in the chat.
-
earthlydarkness
commented
It's just an emote, it's for comedic purposes, this is something the Twitch communities universally want and are upset that we can't have because it's harmless. Surely if you are allowing real-life people to twerk now on your website, you'll allow a fingernail-sized emote that all Twitch users enjoy harmless across your platform.
-
tilchara
commented
These emotes are a very important part of internet culture. They are a silly little motion that is used to express ones self. Much in the same way dance, drawing, writing, paint, music, is used to express ones self. It is a simple motion that does not hurt anyone on it's own. It does not automatically insinuate anything sexual unless you are looking for something sexual. Even the original source, as provided by this post, was a PG movie, something that by the rules is not allowed to have sexual elements.
-
izmaost
commented
Free the dumpy
-
heloseco
commented
It just a cartoon swinging tail.
-
fingmakes
commented
Free the Dumpy
-
Nindessa
commented
The majority of "dumpy" emotes I've seen on the platform were cute cartoon animals shaking their non-detailed butts, not sexualized depictions of the rear (not to say those don't exist, rather that they're a minority). They are an alternative to dancing or bongo emotes, and are generally used as such. I don't see why cute animals dancing should be prohibited.
-
Kingtonton
commented
UGC (User generated content) is a vital part of a thriving, healthy online community. Things become memes, inside jokes, a way of increasing inclusion when a person is 'in on' the thing. Dumpy is used by nearly every streamer I watch, not as something ****, but as something silly and playful and innocent. It should 100% remain.
-
imthe49
commented
J'adore ce stream!