I think it's a wonderful idea to include gifted subs to count for plus points. If you're concerned about someone buying enough subs to count for the streamer, I don't see a valid argument there. Twitch receives the same cut either way, how the subs are earned varies on community. Some genres of content have different sub culture as well. If you have a strong enough community to support the plus program, then regardless of how you got the subs shouldn't it be recognized?
Personally speaking, my community is very heavy handed with gift subs. I'll regularly have hundreds gifted, to the point you'd be hard pressed to find someone without a sub. Yet because they give so much, as the OP said, it does discourage gift subscriptions in communities because being gifted a subscription could take away the possibility of somebody subscribing on their own. I want my community to support me however they wish and I want it to be encouraged by twitch, not discouraged. I love the OPs idea of having a different metric for gifted if people are concerned about gifted subs not representing the community.
I think it's a wonderful idea to include gifted subs to count for plus points. If you're concerned about someone buying enough subs to count for the streamer, I don't see a valid argument there. Twitch receives the same cut either way, how the subs are earned varies on community. Some genres of content have different sub culture as well. If you have a strong enough community to support the plus program, then regardless of how you got the subs shouldn't it be recognized?
Personally speaking, my community is very heavy handed with gift subs. I'll regularly have hundreds gifted, to the point you'd be hard pressed to find someone without a sub. Yet because they give so much, as the OP said, it does discourage gift subscriptions in communities because being gifted a subscription could take away the possibility of somebody subscribing on their own. I want my community to support me however they wish and I want it to be encouraged by twitch, not discouraged. I love the OPs idea of having a different metric for gifted if people are concerned about gifted subs not representing the community.