Settings and activity
2 results found
-
427 votes
This experiment is now closed as the new mobile redesign is rolling out to all users. Thank you for all your feedback during the experiment. We released an update to respect your autoplay settings in the feed, muted the feed on open by default (you can adjust this in your settings), and added mute functionality directly to the feed to give you more control over your viewing experience. We also enabled PIP over feed and have been continuing to improve app performance since launch. Learn more about the new app on our blog and continue to share feedback with us on the improved experience in the mobile category on UserVoice.
N00BERINE
supported this idea
·
An error occurred while saving the comment -
8,359 votes
N00BERINE
supported this idea
·
Firstly, I want to recognize that Twitch has grappled with a growing discoverability issue, and I wanted to commend the developers for attempting to solve this problem.
However, as others have commented in this thread (in ways that may be “harsh” or less constructive than they could’ve been) the overall viewing experience has been replaced by an unoptimized discovery feed. Although I believe that discovery should remain in the minds of future updates, the culture behind Twitch should not be substituted.
Currently, picture-in-picture mode has been essentially voided due to the fact that the Twitch app automatically defaults back to the auto-play discovery page if you leave the app (the way PiP was intended). Further, the autoplay function necessarily pauses whatever is playing on the PiP player.
Also, this UI update has created the consequence of being unable to easily engage with followed channels. Regardless of whether this consequence was intended or not, the fact of the matter is moving towards a purely “recommendations” approach to channel discovery will inevitably lead to a decline of followers. This has been the case with other platforms (i.e. YouTube) in which content creators have voiced a significant decline in channel subscriptions following recommended tab overhauls.
At its current state, the discovery autoplay function of the Twitch Mobile homepage has only one net positive: being free of advertisements. Other than that, it simply confused returning users. Behaviourally, the “shock” of seeing such a radical UI change without any user confirmation or gradual implementation has expectedly garnered a less-than-positive reaction by the community.
Twitch is lucky in that it is the last of the content platforms to have a significant “shorts” feature; perhaps it can learn from the flaws of the others. One thing is certain: the other media platforms did not punish users for failing to embrace short-form content; it happened organically.